3D Printing, Intellectual Property, and - Public Knowledge

0 downloads 216 Views 4MB Size Report
iPhone (or other VGA video source). Image from MakerBot. 1 Ashlee ..... to successfully sue Company X, patent owners wil
IT WILL BE AWESOME IF THEY DON’T SCREW IT UP: 3D Printing, Intellectual Property, and the Fight Over the Next Great Disruptive Technology

Michael Weinberg November 2010

PAGE -1

INTRODUCTION !"#$%%$&'(")'*+#!",#!#-!&")". !"#$ %#&'$ ()#*'$ '#+"%,-,(.+*-$ /.0)12'.,%$ .0$ 3)#4.%($ 510'$ ,1'$ !"# $%&'()# *+# $,-..# /!01$'!2$3# -+4# "-56.6$$# !"756# 2-01$3# -+4# (*)*(#06$ *%/$ 3*0#7#%'06$ )#8,-1'.,%*).#0$ *)#$ '.%9#).%($ 4.'"$ 7*+".%#0$ '"*'$ +*%$ '1)%$ /.(.'*-$ 3.'0$ .%',$ 2":0.+*-$ *',70;$ !"#$ 7*+".%#0$ +*%$ /,4%-,*/$ 2-*%0$ )#f#Y[Y) #I66#Jd#\)I)>)#f#Y[Z) d #I66#Jd#\)I)>)#f#Y[J) ? Y

PAGE -8 .0$.%$'"#$213-.+$/,7*.%$,)$'"#$+,2:$.0$*$2),'#+'#/$!)3#YZi#])Y[d3# Y[iNY[#D>)>)C)j#Yi[gE) F # I66#Jd#\)I)>)#f#Y[Y)

# I66#`664$#-+4#>-(.%+#>!)#:)#G%5(!0#=-.1%+&#B-5'%+6#>!)3#ZYJ#\)I)#J[Y3#JYk#DYi[iE) # Yd#\)I)>)#f#YYYg)# BQ # I66#Yd#\I>#f#YYZdD5E) B? $ O)6$.!80(#/0!(63#(0-46,-01#.-/#_4!6$#+!(#20!(65(#(0-46#406$$#%+#-# '1:*1:"*TU5"/:401'42'2*;'%)26V

C$# /%('# 46$%&+# 2-(6+($3# (0-46# 406$$# 20!(65(%!+# $'!8.4# +!(# 20!:%46# -# $%&+%75-+(# )#ZbY#D5E) ?Z

!

&'()%"*+a,*H$88)0'1'"2*2)3:*42*9:'0(';"%2"*P:11/,bb>>>61:'0(';"%2"63$8R* 45%"4A=*"c'21*1$*455$>*A"2'(0"%2*1$*2:4%"I*A'23)22I*40A*3$554!$%41"*$0* A"2'(026

=%$ *//.'.,%$ ',$ *''*+9.%($ '"#$ +,72*%.#0$ '"*'$ 7*9#$ ?@$ 2).%'.%($ 2!$$%C@# 7.6(;26$# .%$ 71+"$ '"#$ 0*7#$ 4*:$ '"*'$ +,2:).("'$ ",-/#)0$ 0'.(7*'.K#$ '"#$ C@#7.6$#/%('#%+"0%+&6,6+(#5!8.4#$.!/#('6#,-%+$(06-,# -4!2(%!+#!"#J@#20%+(%+&#-+4#%,2.;#('-(#-+;!+6#82.!-4%+&#>C@# 7.6$#(!#-#5!,,8+%(;#$%(6#%$#$!,6'!/#%+"0%+&%+&#!+#0%&'($) 1A6B57;5#8C#08DE67F# 9!/6:603# 5!+(0%%0)#YiiJEE)

PAGE -13 0.72-:$3#+*10#$,