Comments Rubric

Download PDF
3 downloads 310 Views 36KB Size Report
Comment
Kelvin Thompson, Ed.D. Commenting/Interaction Rubric. EME 5050: Fundamentals of Technology for Educators. Dr. Kelvin Tho
Commenting/Interaction Rubric

EME 5050: Fundamentals of Technology for Educators Dr. Kelvin Thompson

Criteria

Superior

Excellent

Good

Fair

Poor

22.5-25 pts.

20-22.5 pts.

17.5-19.75 pts.

15-17.25 pts.

0-14.75 pts.

Substance 40%

Multiple points from original posting clearly built upon/refuted in comment(s) [10 points]

At least one point from original posting clearly built upon/refuted in comment(s) [8.9 points]

Multiple points from original posting vaguely built upon/refuted in comment(s) [7.9 points]

At least one point from original posting vaguely built upon/refuted in comment(s) [6.9 points]

Comment(s) perfunctory with little to no substance (e.g., “Good job”) [5.9 points]

Relevance 40% [Note: Some assignments call for particular kinds of commenter feedback. Refer to modules.]

Comment(s) clearly related to the assigned topic [10 points]

Comment(s) somewhat related to the assigned topic [8.9 points]

Comment(s) somewhat unrelated to the assigned topic [7.9 points]

Comment(s) quite unrelated to the assigned topic [6.9 points]

Comment(s) have no relevance to the assigned topic [5.9 points]

Tone 20%

Comment(s) positive/encouraging in tone and language (even if critical in substance) [5 points]

Comment(s) respectful in tone and language [4.45 points]

Comment(s) appropriate in tone and language [3.95 points]

Comment(s) somewhat inappropriate in tone or language [3.45 points]

Comment(s) very inappropriate in tone or language [2.95 points]

Note: See Communications Protocols distributed at beginning of the course for additional guidance.

EME5050 Comments Rubric Kelvin Thompson, Ed.D.