Download Report (PDF) - Environment America

Download PDF
1 downloads 220 Views 2MB Size Report
Comment
May 15, 2012 - assistance. Environment America Research & Policy Center thanks the Energy Foundation for .... Arizon
!

! ! !

!

"#$$%&!'(!)*%!+',-.!! /'0(1!2,&)*%&!'(!,!/,33'(!'4!/,5!

! ! ! !

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`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a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b'&YX!,(-! I'&)*!7,&'30(,!Q'#3-!5%%!)*%!3,&1%5)!'9%&,33!&%-#;)0'(5!0(!1,5'30(%!;'(5#$M)0'(!,(-!13'D,3! Q,&$0(1!M'33#)0'(F!!?%,(Q*03%X!0(-090-#,3!4,$030%5!Q'#3-!D%!,D3%!)'!5,9%!)*%!$'5)! !"##$%&'(&)*$&+',-.&/'0(1&2,%)*$%&'(&,&/,33'(&'4&/,5& 9&

1,5'30(%c,5!Q%33!,5!)*%!$'5)!$'(%>c0(!O>'$0(1X!?0550550MM0X!?'(),(,X!I'&)*!d,Y'),! ,(-!I'&)*!7,&'30(,F! ! C*%!M&'M'5%-!5),(-,&-5!D#03-!'(!)*%!&%;%()3>!40(,30a%-!301*)[-#)>!5),(-,&-5!4'&!$'-%3! >%,&5!@AB@[@ABKX!Q*0;*!&%M&%5%()%-!)*%!3,&1%5)!0(;&%,5%!0(!4#%3!%;'('$>!0(!'9%&!WA!>%,&5! ,(-!)*%!40&5)[%9%&!13'D,3!Q,&$0(1!),03M0M%!M'33#)0'(!5),(-,&-5F!!C*%5%!5),(-,&-5!Q%&%!40&5)! -%9%3'M%-!D,5%-!'(!5),(-,&-5!;&%,)%-!D>!7,304'&(0,!,(-!,-'M)%-!D>!BW!')*%&!5),)%5.! :&0a'(,X!7'((%;)0;#)X!?,0(%X!?,&>3,(-X!?,55,;*#5%))5X!I%Q!P,$M5*0&%X!I%Q!6%&5%>X!I%Q! ?%E0;'X!I%Q!b'&YX!J&%1'(X!=%((5>39,(0,X!R%&$'()!,(-!O,5*0(1)'(F!! ! \>!&%`#0&0(1!)*%!,9%&,1%!;,&5!,(-!301*)!)&#;Y5!)'!,;*0%9%!,!5),(-,&-!'4!,)!3%,5)!LGFL!$M1! $03%5!M%&!1,33'(!D>!@A@LX!)*%!,-$0(05)&,)0'(]5!(%Q!5),(-,&-5!Q'#3-!>0%3-!$,_'&!5,90(15! D%>'(-!_#5)!,!50(13%!5#$$%&F!C*%!I,)#&,3!+%5'#&;%5!d%4%(5%!7'#(;03!M&'_%;)5!)*,)!%9%(! D%>'(-!4#%3!%440;0%(;>!5),(-,&-5!;#&&%()3>!0(!M3,;%X!)*%!(%Q!M&'M'5,3!Q033!;#)!'#&!'03! ;'(5#$M)0'(!D>!SBFG!$0330'(!1,33'(5!'4!'03!M%&!-,>!D>!@AWAF!C*,)]5!,5!$#;*!Q%!;#&&%()3>! 0$M'&)!4&'$!",#-0!:&,D0,!,(-!Z&,`!;'$D0(%-F!:(-!)*,)!,35'!$%,(5!;#))0(1!@VS!$0330'(! $%)&0;!)'(5!'4!;,&D'(!M'33#)0'(!4'&!%,;*!4#33!>%,&!D>!@AWAc)*%!%`#09,3%()!'4!)*%!M'33#)0'(! M#$M%-!'#)!D>!SK!;',3[40&%-!M'Q%&!M3,()5FS!20(,30a0(1!)*%5%!5),(-,&-5!Q033!D%!,!&%5'#(-0(1! 90;)'&>!4'&!:$%&0;,(!4,$030%5X!-&,$,)0;,33>!&%-#;0(1!'03!;'(5#$M)0'(X!;#))0(1!M'33#)0'(X!,(-! >0%3-0(1!;'5)!5,90(15!,)!)*%!M#$Mc(')!_#5)!4'&!'(%!5#$$%&X!D#)!4'&!>%,&5!)'!;'$%F! ! :$%&0;,!*,5!)*%!Q'&Y4'&;%!,(-!)*%!)%;*('3'1>!&%,->!)'!D#03-!;3%,(%&X!$'&%!4#%3!%440;0%()! ;,&5!)*,)!*%3M!D&%,Y!'#&!-,(1%&'#5!-%M%(-%(;%!'(!'03F!O%!'(3>!&%`#0&%!'#&!3%,-%&5!)'!M#)! :$%&0;,(!0(1%(#0)>!)'!Q'&Y!)'!$'9%!#5!D%>'(-!'03F!C*%!JD,$,!,-$0(05)&,)0'(!5*'#3-! $'9%!;3%,(!;,&5!0()'!)*%!4,5)!3,(%!D>!5%))0(1!5),(-,&-5!)*,)!&%`#0&%!(%Q!;,&5!,(-!301*)! )&#;Y5!)'!$%%)!,!5),(-,&-!'4!LGFL!$03%5!M%&!1,33'(!D>!@A@LF!

!"##$%&'(&)*$&+',-.&/'0(1&2,%)*$%&'(&,&/,33'(&'4&/,5& :&

C*%!H(0)%-!"),)%5! I%%-5!)'!/%)!J44!J03! ! :$%&0;,]5!-,(1%&'#5!-%M%(-%(;%!'(!'03! *,&$5!'#&!%(90&'($%()!,(-!)*&%,)%(5! '#&!%;'('$>F!J#&!-%M%(-%(;%!'(!)*05! -0&)>!%(%&1>!5'#&;%!-%9,5),)%5!'#&!5*'&%5! ,5!Q%!*,9%!5,-3>!5%%(!,3'(1!)*%!/#34! 7',5)!,5!Q%33!,5!'(!')*%&!)&%,5#&%-! Q,)%&Q,>5!,;&'55!)*%!;'#()&>X!0(;3#-0(1! )*%!e,3,$,a''!&09%&!,(-!)*%!b%33'Q5)'(%! &09%&F!Z)!,35'!%E,;%&D,)%5!)*%!)*&%,)!M'5%-! D>!13'D,3!Q,&$0(1!D>!5M%Q0(1!(%,&3>!@! D0330'(!$%)&0;!)'(5!'4!;,&D'(!M'33#)0'(! 0()'!'#&!,0&X!'&!(%,&3>!'(%!)*0&-!'4!)*%! 13'D,3!Q,&$0(1!M'33#)0'(!Q%!%$0)F ! U

!

/%))0(1!:$%&0;,(5!4&'$!M'0()!:!)'!M'0()! \!;'(5#$%5!,D'#)!)Q'[)*0&-5!'4!)*%! (%,&3>!BV!$0330'(!D,&&%35!'4!'03!;'(5#$%-! %,;*!-,>!0(!)*%!H(0)%-!"),)%5FV!!UFL!$0330'(! '4!)*'5%!D,&&%35!'4!'03!-0&%;)3>!4#%3! M,55%(1%&!;,&5!,(-!301*)!-#)>!)&#;Y5!5#;*! ,5!"HR5X!9,(5X!,(-!M0;Y#M!)&#;Y5X!Q*0;*! $%,(5!&%-#;0(1!'#&!-%M%(-%(;%!'(!'03! &%`#0&%5!D#03-0(1!;,&5!,(-!)&#;Y5!)*,)!,&%! $#;*!;3%,(%&!,(-!$'&%!4#%3!%440;0%()FBA! ! !

LGFL!$M1!N!O%!P,9%! )*%!C%;*('3'1>!)'!/%)! C*%&%! ! :$%&0;,(!0(1%(#0)>!*,5!109%(!#5!)*%! )%;*('3'1>!)'-,>!)*,)!;,(!$,Y%!;,&5!,(-! )&#;Y5!,;*0%9%!,!LGFL!$M1!43%%)[Q0-%! 5),(-,&-F!\>!,MM3>0(1!%E05)0(1!,(-! %$%&10(1!4#%3!5,90(1!)%;*('3'10%5!)'!

;'(9%()0'(,3!0()%&(,3!;'$D#5)0'(!%(10(%! 9%*0;3%5X!Q*03%!&,$M0(1!#M!M&'-#;)0'(!'4! *>D&0-5!,(-!M3#1[0(!%3%;)&0;!9%*0;3%5X! ,#)'$,Y%&5!;,(!-%309%&!,!4#33!&,(1%!'4! ;,&5!,(-!)&#;Y5!)*,)!#5%!3%55!'03!,(-!%$0)! 3%55!13'D,3!Q,&$0(1!M'33#)0'(FBB! ! "#$%&$'(#$)*!($'&+$)*!,#-./0'(#$! &$1($&!%&2(,*&0!;,(!D%!$,-%!$#;*!$'&%! %440;0%()!D>!,MM3>0(1!4#%3[5,90(1! )%;*(0`#%5!5#;*!,5!-'Q(50a%-! )#&D';*,&1%-!%(10(%5X!%(*,(;%-! ,%&'->(,$0;!-%501(5X!*01*[5)&%(1)*! 301*)Q%01*)!$,)%&0,35X!50E[5M%%-!,(-! 5%9%([5M%%-!)&,(5$0550'(5!,(-!$'&%! ;30$,)%[4&0%(-3>!,0&!;'(-0)0'(0(1! 5>5)%$5FB@!O*03%!,!1&'Q0(1!(#$D%&!'4! ,#)'$,Y%&5!,&%!,3&%,->!#50(1!5'$%!'4! )*%5%!)%;*(0`#%5X!,MM3>0(1!)*%!4#33!&,(1%! '4!)*%5%!)%;*('3'10%5!Q033!501(040;,()3>! 0(;&%,5%!4#%3!%440;0%(;>F! ! :!LGFL!$M1!5),(-,&-!Q033!,35'!*%3M!D&0(1! -#+&!23.+(45&*&,'+(,!%&2(,*&0!0()'!)*%! $,&Y%)M3,;%F!C*%5%!9%*0;3%5!;,(! 501(040;,()3>!0$M&'9%!4#%3!%440;0%(;>!,(-! 3'Q%&!13'D,3!Q,&$0(1!M'33#)0'(!%$0550'(5! D>!;'$D0(0(1!,(!%440;0%()!1,5'30(%!%(10(%! Q0)*!,(!%3%;)&0;!$')'&F!:#)'$,Y%&5!,&%! ,35'!5%330(1!6*/15($!&*&,'+(,!%&2(,*&0!)*,)! &%`#0&%!('!1,5'30(%!,)!,33F!83%;)&0;!9%*0;3%5! 30Y%!)*%!7*%9&'3%)!R'3)!,(-!I055,(!T%,4! *,9%!&'33%-!0()'!-%,3%&5*0M5!)*05!M,5)! >%,&X!,(-!$'&%!$'-%35!Q033!4'33'Q!04!,! 5)&'(1!5),(-,&-!05!5%)!0(!M3,;%F!

! 73%,(!7,&5!O033!7#)! J03!7'(5#$M)0'(! !

!"##$%&'(&)*$&+',-.&/'0(1&2,%)*$%&'(&,&/,33'(&'4&/,5& ;&

\%;,#5%!)*%!$,_'&0)>!'4!)*%!'03!;'(5#$%-! 0(!)*%!H(0)%-!"),)%5!1'%5!)'Q,&-!40330(1! )*%!1,5!),(Y5!'4!'#&!;,&5!,(-!301*)!)&#;Y5X! 5)&'(1!;3%,(!;,&!5),(-,&-5!&%M&%5%()!)*%! D%5)!,(-!$'5)!0$$%-0,)%!'MM'&)#(0)>!)'! 3';Y!0(!501(040;,()!&%-#;)0'(5!0(!'#&!'03! #5%F!Z4!'#&!43%%)!'4!9%*0;3%5!$%)!,!LGFL! $M1!5),(-,&-X!:$%&0;,(5!Q'#3-!#5%! &'#1*3>!BK!D0330'(!4%Q%&!1,33'(5!'4! 1,5'30(%!-#&0(1!)*%!5#$$%&!)*05!>%,&c '2)'!$&)+*3!0*)02&0!#/+!,)+07!&86&,'&4!#(*! !

,#$0/-6'(#$!($!2)*9:!! ! O*03%!)*%5%!&%-#;)0'(5!0(!'03!#5%!,&%! 501(040;,()!0(!)*%!5;'M%!'4!,!5#$$%&X!)*%0&! %44%;)!'9%&!)0$%!Q'#3-!*,9%!)>! M&'4'#(-!D%(%40)5!4'&!'#&!(,)0'(]5!%(%&1>! 5%;#&0)>X!'#&!%(90&'($%()X!,(-!'#&! *%,3)*F!20(,30a0(1!,!LGFL!$M1!5),(-,&-! Q'#3-X!0(!%44%;)X!D%!)*%!50(13%!D011%5)! 5)%M!Q%!*,9%!%9%&!),Y%(!)'!1%)!'44!'03F!!

! "#$!%&!'()(*+!,#-!.)+#/01*!)12!./#3)/!4)-5016!750++0#1!')8016+! !!

!"#"$% 7,304'&(0,! C%E,5! 23'&0-,! I%Q!b'&Y! I'&)*!7,&'30(,! J*0'! Z330('05! =%((5>39,(0,! /%'&10,! ?0;*01,(!

&'(%!#)'*+,%!"#"$-'.$% /+#((0*,1% BXU@LXUUKXUGA! BX@LGXBL@XG@U! BXA@SXAB@X@KS! SGGXSWBXVWB! SAGXAA@XVB@! KBVX@B@XKVB! KB@XWWKXAUS! KAWXGKGXGBV! LKUXAUWXUKV! LG@XUKVXKLL!

2(03#(%4#56'*+%70((8"'0*% 9$.8:$.%!"#"$-'.$%/6$"5':%"0*,% ;&)&)*,)& =#$%0>,(5&B033&5C$(-&,A'")&I687& A0330'(&,)&)*$&1,5&C"#CE&J")&B0)*&,&:9E:& #C1&5),(-,%-G&B$&>'"3-&&>")&)*,)&401"%$& ($,%3D&0(&*,34G&,3'(150-$&'"%&>")5&0(&'03& >'(5"#C)0'(E& & K4&)*$&>,%5&'(&)*$&%',-&)'-,D&#$)&,&:9E:& #C1&5),(-,%-G&=#$%0>,(5&B'"3-&5,@$& '@$%&I;9&A0330'(&,)&)*$&1,5&C"#C&)*05& 5"##$%E&& &

!"##$%&'(&)*$&+',-.&/'0(1&2,%)*$%&'(&,&/,33'(&'4&/,5& *E&F*$&,@$%,1$& =#$%0>,(&4,#03D&B'"3-&5,@$&,A'")&698& 1,33'(5&'4&'03G&,#'"()0(1&)'&I::6&0(& )*$0%&C'>M$)5&AD&)*$&$(-&'4&)*$&5"##$%E& N')&'(3D&>'"3-&)*$D&,44'%-&,&5"##$%& %',-&)%0C&)'&,&4,@'%0)$&-$5)0(,)0'(&#'%$& & &

$,503DG&A")&)*$D&>'"3-&A''M&,&*')$3&,(-& 5)0>M&,%'"(-&4'%&,&>'"C3$&'4&$O)%,&-,D5& B0)*&)*$&#'($D&)*$D&*,@$&5,@$-E&K(& 5'#$&'4&)*$&5),)$5&B*$%$&4,#030$5&-%0@$& )*$&#'5)G&)*$D&5),(-&)'&1,0(&*"(-%$-5& #'%$&)*,(&)*,)E&& &

! "#$!%&!'()(*+!,#-!')8016+!)(!(9*!:;5$!$*-!'$0(1! ?0550550MM0! ?'(),(,! I'&)*!d,Y'),! I'&)*!7,&'30(,! JY3,*'$,! "'#)*!d,Y'),! I%Q!?%E0;'! R%&$'()! Z(-0,(,!

&'(%!#)'*+,%=$5% >08,$?0(.%/+#((0*,1% @KL! @AG! BVS! BVW! BUU! BUL! BU@! BUA! BSU! BSL!

! !

?'90(1!73%,(!7,&5! 0()'!)*%!2,5)!T,(%! ! C*%!4'#(-,)0'(!4'&!5)&'(1!4%-%&,3!;3%,(! 9%*0;3%!5),(-,&-5!;'$%5!4&'$! $'$%()#$!D#03)!0(!5),)%5!,;&'55!)*%! ;'#()&>F!7,304'&(0,!D%1,(!)*%!$'9%$%()! )'Q,&-!;3%,(%&!;,&5!0(!@AA@!D>!M,550(1!,! 3,(-$,&Y!;3%,(!;,&5!3,Q!)*,)!),&1%)%-! &%-#;)0'(5!0(!13'D,3!Q,&$0(1!M'33#)0'(! 5M%Q0(1!4&'$!),03M0M%5F!C*%!d05)&0;)!'4! 7'3#$D0,!,(-!)*0&)%%(!')*%&!5),)%5c :&0a'(,X!7'((%;)0;#)X!?,0(%X!?,&>3,(-X! ?,55,;*#5%))5X!I%Q!6%&5%>X!I%Q!?%E0;'X!

@0*$A%!#)$.%=$5%>08,$?0(.% ^BXABAFUV! ^SLAFGL! ^SLBFWS! ^S@KFBK! ^SAUFKS! ^KVSFWS! ^KULFAV! ^KKGFVA! ^SAWFVS! ^KLKFSS! I%Q!b'&YX!J&%1'(X!=%((5>39,(0,X!+*'-%! Z53,(-X!R%&$'()!,(-!O,5*0(1)'(c ,-'M)%-!7,304'&(0,]5!*05)'&0;!;3%,(!;,&! 5),(-,&-5FBW! !

=&%50-%()!JD,$,!)''Y!,;)0'(!)'!D#03-!'(! )*%5%!(15!0(!%,&3>!@ABAX!;,330(1!4'&! (%Q!4%-%&,3!301*)!-#)>!;3%,(!;,&!5),(-,&-5! 4'&!$'-%3!>%,&5!@AB@[@ABK!)*,)!Q'#3-! 0(;&%,5%!4#%3!%440;0%(;>!)'!WLFL!$M1F!C*05! &%M&%5%()%-!)*%!3,&1%5)!0(;&%,5%!0(!4#%3! %;'('$>!0(!$'&%!)*,(!WA!>%,&5!,(-!5%)! )*%!40&5)!%9%&!4%-%&,3!),03M0M%!13'D,3! Q,&$0(1!M'33#)0'(!5),(-,&-5F!O*03%!)*%5%! 5),(-,&-5!Q033!M&'90-%!501(040;,()!D%(%40)5! 4'&!:$%&0;,]5!%;'('$>!,(-!%(90&'($%()X!

!"##$%&'(&)*$&+',-.&/'0(1&2,%)*$%&'(&,&/,33'(&'4&/,5& L&

5)033!1&%,)%&!0$M&'9%$%()5!0(!4#%3! %;'('$>!,&%!(%;%55,&>!)'!)>!1%)! :$%&0;,!'44!'03F! ! 6#5)!'9%&!,!$'()*!,4)%&!40(,30a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a%-!0(!)*%!;'$0(1!$'()*5F!!\>! $,Y0(1!(%Q!;,&5!,(-!301*)!)&#;Y5!$%%)! 5),(-,&-5!)*,)!,;*0%9%!,)!3%,5)!LGFL!$M1! D>!@A@LX!)*%!,-$0(05)&,)0'(!Q'#3-!D%! *%3M0(1!:$%&0;,(5!5,9%!SBFG!!$0330'(! 1,33'(5!'4!'03!,!-,>X!3%,-0(1!)'!5,90(15! ,;&'55!)*%!;'#()&>!'4!^KU!D0330'(!,!>%,&X! %9%(!,;;'#()0(1!4'&!)*%!;'5)5!'4!,-'M)0(1! (%Q!)%;*('3'10%5FBG! ! ")&'(1!;3%,(!;,&5!5),(-,&-5!%(_'>! '9%&Q*%3$0(1!M#D30;!5#MM'&)F!?'&%!)*,(! SG!M%&;%()!'4!30Y%3>!9')%&5!M'33%-!0(!@ABA! ! !

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

! 7'(;3#50'(!

! Z)!05!,D#(-,()3>!;3%,&!)*,)!Q%!,&%! 5M%(-0(1!)''!$#;*!$'(%>!,)!)*%!M#$MX! ,(-!_%'M,&-0a0(1!'#&!%(90&'($%()!,5!Q%33! ,5!'#&!4,$030%5]!40(,(;%5!)*&'#1*!'#&! -%M%(-%(;%!'(!'03F!"%))0(1!)*%!5)&'(1%5)! M'550D3%!5),(-,&-!&%`#0&0(1!;,&5!,(-! )&#;Y5!)'!%$0)!3%55!13'D,3!Q,&$0(1! M'33#)0'(!,(-!#5%!3%55!1,5!Q'#3-!5,9%! -&09%&5!D0330'(5!'4!-'33,&5!,((#,33>F!C*%! JD,$,!,-$0(05)&,)0'(!5*'#3-!$'9%!;3%,(! ;,&5!0()'!)*%!4,5)!3,(%!D>!5%))0(1! 5),(-,&-5!)*,)!&%`#0&%!(%Q!;,&5!,(-!301*)! )&#;Y5!)'!,9%&,1%!LGFL!$03%5!M%&!1,33'(!D>! @A@LF!

!"##$%&'(&)*$&+',-.&/'0(1&2,%)*$%&'(&,&/,33'(&'4&/,5& P&

?%)*'-'3'1>! ! O%!'D),0(%-!5),)%[D>[5),)%!-,),!'(!)'),3! 9%*0;3%!$03%5!)&,9%33%-!fR?Cg!4'&!6#(%X! 6#3>!,(-!:#1#5)!'4!@ABB!4&'$!HF"F! d%M,&)$%()!'4!C&,(5M'&),)0'(X!2%-%&,3! P01*Q,>!:-$0(05)&,)0'(X!"-),,0=!>#/;5*! "-*12+F!O%!,-_#5)%-!)*05!)'),3!R?C!401#&%! )'!&%43%;)!)*%!4,;)!)*,)X!(,)0'(,33>X!301*)[! -#)>!9%*0;3%5!,;;'#()!4'&!,MM&'E0$,)%3>! UVF@Lh!M%&;%()!'4!$03%5!-&09%(X!M%&!HF"F! d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iC&,(53,)0(1!:#)'!"),(-,&-5!0()'!J(N +',-!2#%3!8440;0%(;>Xj!"%M)%$D%&!@ABBF! C*%!-044%&%(;%!0(!)*%!,$'#()!'4!4#%3! ;'(5#$%-!#(-%&!)*%!)Q'!-044%&%()!4#%3! %;'('$>!5),(-,&-5!&%M&%5%()5!)*%! 5,90(15!)*,)!;'#3-!D%!'D),0(%-!4&'$! *01*%&!5),(-,&-5F! ! O%!%5)0$,)%-!Q*,)!)*05!Q'#3-!$%,(!0(! )%&$5!'4!&%-#;%-!13'D,3!Q,&$0(1! M'33#)0'(!D>!;'(9%&)0(1!1,5'30(%!5,90(15!

)'!,(!%`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d%M,&)$%()!'4!8(%&1>X!8(%&1>! Z(4'&$,)0'(!:-$0(05)&,)0'(X!4**G/@! M*()0/!.)+#/01*!)12!K0*+*/!:-0=*+X!S!?,>! @AB@F! ! C'!;,3;#3,)%!Q*,)!)*05!Q'#3-!$%,(!4'&! 0(-090-#,3!;'(5#$%&5X!Q%!,55#$%-!)*,)! %9%&>!*'#5%*'3-!0(!,!5),)%!05!&%5M'(50D3%! 4'&!,(!%`#,3!5*,&%!'4!5),)%Q0-%!R?C!,(-! %5)0$,)%-!5,90(15!'(!,!*'#5%*'3-!D,505F! O%!;,3;#3,)%-!)*%!(#$D%&!'4!*'#5%*'3-5! 0(!%9%&>!5),)%!#50(1!M'M#3,)0'(!401#&%5! ,(-!,9%&,1%!*'#5%*'3-!50a%!-,),!4&'$! HF"F!7%(5#5!\#&%,#X!='M#3,)0'(!85)0$,)%5! =&'1&,$X!A&%&!:#$;/)(0#1!7+(05)(*+X!@A! 6#3>!@ABAX!,9,03,D3%!,)! 4,;)40(-%&F;%(5#5F1'9k*'$%k%(k'440;0,3l%! 5)0$,)%5l@AAVF*)$3F!O%!-090-%-!'#&! 5),)%Q0-%!1,5'30(%!;'5)!5,90(15!D>!)*%! (#$D%&!'4!*'#5%*'3-5!)'!-%&09%!,!M%&[ *'#5%*'3-!5,90(15!401#&%F!

!"##$%&'(&)*$&+',-.&/'0(1&2,%)*$%&'(&,&/,33'(&'4&/,5& 6Q&

! ! E$$*120L!D!.)+#/01*!)12!6/#3)/!?)-5016!*50++0#1!+)8016+!?0(9!8*90=/*+!)(!NOPN!5$6! +()12)-2B!+;55*-!A&%AP!!! !

!"#"$% :3,D,$,! :3,5Y,! :&0a'(,! :&Y,(5,5! 7,304'&(0,! 7'3'&,-'! 7'((%;)0;#)! dF7F! d%3,Q,&%! 23'&0-,! /%'&10,! P,Q,00! Z-,*'! Z330('05! Z(-0,(,! Z'Q,! e,(5,5! e%()#;Y>! T'#050,(,! ?,0(%! ?,&>3,(-! ?,55,;*#5%))5! ?0;*01,(! ?0((%5'),! ?0550550MM0! ?055'#&0! ?'(),(,! I%D&,5Y,! I%9,-,! I%Q!P,$M5*0&%! I%Q!6%&5%>! I%Q!?%E0;'! I%Q!b'&Y!

&'(% !#)'*+,% 9#*B% B@! GS! WK! BK! @V! GB! WV! LB! BW! WL! BU! GU! BS! G@! BA! @L! @K! @U! WB! @G! @S! GW! WW! BV! @! BG! W! BL! GV! WA! GG! U! LA!

&'(%!#)'*+,% =$5% >08,$?0(.% /+#((0*,1% BKK! BBU! BWL! BKB! BGL! B@U! B@V! SW! BKL! BWU! BLU! BBL! BKA! B@S! BSL! BGU! BGS! BGS! BGB! BGU! BGS! B@B! BGA! BLU! @AG! BKG! BVS! BK@! BAV! BGL! B@B! BUA! BA@!

&'(%!#)'*+,% !"#"$-'.$%/+#((0*,1% WB@XL@GXKLS! WAXWV@XUVA! W@AXUA@XALA! BUGXGSVXSLA! BXU@LXUUKXUGA! @LBXLGSXUKA! BSSXWGUXGLS! BVXG@AXAWU! LKXKGSXAUG! BXA@SXAB@X@KS! LKUXAUWXUKV! L@XBKUXUA@! V@XS@UXA@V! KB@XWWKXAUS! GWKXVGAX@GL! BUAX@VUXKAL! BKWXSGWXUBV! @LWX@@GXLKW! @GWXKBAXAL@! U@XK@LXWKG! WBSXGVBXAVW! WAUXUL@XUVA! LG@XUKVXKLL! W@VXSSVXUWU! @@SX@@LXALU! WUUXLGVXWWB! UAXUAAXAVW! BBKXUWUXLVA! BAVXWAGXAGA! SLX@UBXUWB! WUVXLKUXAUS! BG@XSVLXKGK! SGGXSWBXVWB!

2(03#(% 4#56'*+% 70((8"'0*% 9$.8:$.% !"#"$-'.$% /6$"5':%"0*,% ;&39,(0,! +*'-%!Z53,(-! "'#)*!7,&'30(,! "'#)*!d,Y'),! C%((%55%%! C%E,5! H),*! R%&$'()! R0&10(0,! O,5*0(1)'(! O%5)!R0&10(0,! O05;'(50(! O>'$0(1! !!

L! G! WS! K! WU! GL! GK! @B! S! @A! W@! BB! V! @@! GA! WG! @W! B! !!

CJC:T!

!!

BUU! BVW! BWL! BUL! BWG! B@A! B@A! BGV! BU@! BLS! BGB! BS@! BSU! BGV! B@V! BGA! BGV! @KL! !!

SAGXAA@XVB@! LGX@VBX@BA! KBVX@B@XKVB! @SAXSVUXBAL! @AWX@UGX@VA! KAWXGKGXGBV! GVXSAKXUAU! @KUXUUSXVWU! LUXSALXU@A! WVBXKALXLVV! BX@LGXBL@XG@U! BLBX@@BXKAU! GLXSWSXVAG! GLGXLLKX@WK! WWKXVBBXBWB! BAKXSSUXWSW! WWUXSWKXGA@! KAX@B@XSWA! !!

BGW!

BKXKWUXBSKXABS!

KX@AUXA@K! GSUXSLA! LXGKAXWWA! @XWUSXVGS! BXSV@XLVU! LXW@BXGLV! GWUXW@G! @XWSBXBAW! LBSXKSV! WXGLWX@GV! BBXALVXWGG! BXWWWXLAA! GAWXW@L! GXAAUXWKA! @XVSAXVGG! VGBXLVB! @XVUSXAWV! LWAXVKS! A! !! BGKXSBUXGKB!

^@XKLGXAVAXVSS! ^@AGXBUVX@G@! ^@XWLBXBLAXLUK! ^BXABUXGSBXKSG! ^ULAXVGUXAWK! ^@XWGKXUSWXB@K! ^BVKXBV@XSSB! ^BXABWXSASXL@G! ^@@AXSV@XLUV! ^BXGS@XU@UXKLU! ^GXK@LXWBGXBLK! ^LSKXAAWXBAK! ^BUAXL@SXLAS! ^BXSBWXKSSXABB! ^BXWVKXGVKXKWU! ^GA@XLLGXGKU! ^BX@SWXVUSXKBA! ^@@VXWLAX@UV!

^SAUFKS! ^S@KFBK! ^LBAFSG! ^KVSFWS! ^LKAF@W! ^GKSFKB! ^GSGFWL! ^LK@FUA! ^KULFAV! ^LVAFKL! ^LBUFWK! ^KLKF@S! ^SAWFVS! ^LKAFSL! ^LWWFAA! ^L@SFA@! ^LLUFU@! ^BXABAFUV! !!

^KGXW@LX@GWXABL!

^LLBFB@!

!"##$%&'(&)*$&+',-.&/'0(1&2,%)*$%&'(&,&/,33'(&'4&/,5& 67&

& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& B

!I,)0'(,3!J;%,(0;!,(-!:)$'5M*%&0;!:-$0(05)&,)0'(!I,)0'(,3!730$,)0;!d,),!7%()%&X!"),)%!'4!)*%!730$,)%! I,)0'(,3!J9%&90%QX!:M&03!@AB@X!,9,03,D3%!,)!*))M.kkQQQF(;-;F(',,F1'9k5');k(,)0'(,3kF!! @ !+')Y0([833$,(!?X!O'(1!eeX!"'3'$'(!/?!@AB@F!"%,4''-!7'(),$0(,)0'(!,4)%&!)*%!\=!/#34!J03!"M033!,(-! +05Y5!)'!R#3(%&,D3%!='M#3,)0'(5.!:!7&0)0`#%!'4!)*%!2d:!+05Y!:55%55$%()F!8(90&'($%(),3!P%,3)*! =%&5M%;)09%X!-'Q(3',-%-!4&'$!*))M.kk-EF-'0F'&1kBAFB@UVk%*MFBBAWKVLX!K!?,>!@AB@F!! W !HF"F!d%M,&)$%()!'4!8(%&1>X!8(%&1>!Z(4'&$,)0'(!:-$0(05)&,)0'(!E11;)/!71*-6@!F;(/##G!A&%AX!7,&D'(! d0'E0-%!8$0550'(5!D>!"%;)'&!,(-!"'#&;%X!6,(#,&>!@AB@X!,9,03,D3%!,)!*))M.kkQQQF%0,F1'9k4'&%;,5)5k,%'k%&kF! G !HF"F!d%M,&)$%()!'4!8(%&1>X!8(%&1>!Z(4'&$,)0'(!:-$0(05)&,)0'(X!:*(-#/*;5!Q)806)(#-I!HF"F!=&'-#;)! "#MM30%-!'4!7&#-%!J03!,(-!=%)&'3%#$!=&'-#;)5X!?,&;*!@AB@X!,9,03,D3%!,)! *))M.kkQQQF%0,F1'9k-(,9kM%)k*05)kT%,4P,(-3%&F,5*Em(nM%)!7'(5#$M)0'(X!6,(#,&>!@AB@X!,9,03,D3%!,)! *))M.kkQQQF%0,F1'9k4'&%;,5)5k,%'k%&kF!! K !8(90&'($%()!:$%&0;,!+%5%,&;*!,(-!='30;>!7%()%&!,(-!2&'()0%&!/&'#MX!:/;6!R1!J)-+I!:#?*-016!E5*-0=)! "#?)-2!)!J/*)1*-!H;(;-*X!6,(#,&>!@ABAF!! S !I,)#&,3!+%5'#&;%5!d%4%(5%!7'#(;03X!M*/0*8016!:)01!)(!(9*!:;5$X!:M&03!@AB@X!,9,03,D3%!,)! *))M.kkQQQF(&-;F'&1k%(%&1>k&%30%90(1M,0(,))*%M#$MF,5MF! U !O'&3-!+%5'#&;%5!Z(5)0)#)%X!+%-#;0(1!/&%%(*'#5%!/,5!8$0550'(5!0(!)*%!H(0)%-!"),)%5.!H50(1!8E05)0(1! 2%-%&,3!:#)*'&0)0%5!,(-!"),)%!:;)0'(X!6#3>!@ABAF!! V !"%%!(')%!@F! BA !"%%!(')%!WF!! BB !H(0'(!'4!7'(;%&(%-!";0%()05)5!,(-!I,)#&,3!+%5'#&;%5!d%4%(5%!7'#(;03X!C*%!+',-!:*%,-.!C*%!\%(%40)5!'4! ")&'(1!2#%3!8440;0%(;>!,(-!='33#)0'(!"),(-,&-5!4'&!I%Q!7,&5!,(-!C&#;Y5X!"%M)%$D%&!@ABAF! B@ !ZD0-F! BW !8(90&'($%()!:$%&0;,!+%5%,&;*!,(-!='30;>!7%()%&!,(-!2&'()0%&!/&'#MX!"),)%!T%,-%&5*0M!,(-!)*%! I,)0'(,3!73%,(!7,&5!=&'1&,$.!+%-#;0(1!J03!d%M%(-%(;%!,(-!7#))0(1!/3'D,3!O,&$0(1!='33#)0'(X!?,&;*! @ABAF! BG !"%%!(')%!LF! BL !C*%!?%33$,(!/&'#MX!='33.!R')%&5!J9%&Q*%3$0(13>!"#MM'&)!")&0;)%&!2#%3!8440;0%(;>!"),(-,&-5X!BL! "%M)%$D%&!@ABAF&

!"##$%&'(&)*$&+',-.&/'0(1&2,%)*$%&'(&,&/,33'(&'4&/,5& 68&