Granted & Noted List October Term 2014 - Supreme Court of the ...

1 downloads 137 Views 168KB Size Report
Nov 10, 2014 - Author: J. Kagan. Result: VACATED AND REMANDED. Granted: 6/30/14. Decided: 4/29/15. 13-1032*. CFX DIRECT
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

CASES FOR ARGUMENT IN OCTOBER TERM 2014

As of June 29, 2015

126, Orig.

12-1226

KANSAS V. NEBRASKA AND COLORADO Order: 6/9/14 - Set for oral argument Argument Date: 10/14/14 Decided: 2/24/15 Author: J. Kagan Other: Chief Justice (C/P, D/P) Scalia (C/P, D/P) Thomas (C/P, D/P) Result: Exceptions to Special Master’s Report overruled, and Master’s recommendations adopted.

CFX

YOUNG V. UPS Court: USCA-4 Argument Date: 12/3/14 Author: J. Breyer

Granted: 7/1/14 Decided: 3/25/15 Other: Alito (C/J); Scalia (D) Kennedy (D)

Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

12-1497*

CFX

KELLOGG BROWN & ROOT SERVICES V. UNITED STATES EX REL CARTER Court: USCA-4 Granted: 7/1/14 Argument Date: 1/13/15 Decided: 5/26/15 Author: J. Alito Result: REVERSED IN PART, AFFIRMED IN PART, AND REMANDED

13-271

CFX

ONEOK V. LEARJET Court: USCA-9 Argument Date: 1/12/15 Author: J. Breyer Result: AFFIRMED

13-352

NOTE:

CFX

Granted: 7/1/14 Decided: 4/21/15 Other: Thomas (C/P, C/J); Scalia (D)

B&B HARDWARE V. HARGIS INDUSTRIES Court: USCA-8 Granted: 7/1/14 Argument Date: 12/2/14 Decided: 3/24/15 Author: J. Alito Other: Ginsburg (C); Thomas (D) Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

CASES FOR ARGUMENT IN OCTOBER TERM 2014

13-433*

CFX

INTEGRITY STAFFING SOLUTIONS V. BUSK Court: USCA-9 Granted: 3/3/14 Argument Date: 10/8/14 Decided: 12/9/14 Author: J. Thomas Other: Sotomayor (C) Result: REVERSED

13-435#

CFX

OMNICARE V. LABORERS DIST. COUNCIL CONSTR. INDUSTRY PENSION FUND Court: USCA-6 Granted: 3/3/14 Argument Date: 11/3/14 Decided: 3/24/15 Author: J. Kagan Other: Scalia (C/P, C/J); Thomas (C/J) Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

13-485

CSX

COMPTROLLER OF TREASURY OF MD V. WYNNE Court: CA-MD Granted: 5/27/14 Argument Date: 11/12/14 Decided: 5/18/15 Author: J. Alito Other: Scalia (D); Thomas (D) Ginsburg (D) Result: AFFIRMED

13-502#

CFX

REED V. TOWN OF GILBERT Court: USCA-9 Argument Date: 1/12/15 Author: J. Thomas

Granted: 7/1/14 Decided: 6/18/15 Other: Alito (C); Breyer (C/J) Kagan (C/J)

Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

13-517*

13-534

NOTE:

CFX

CFX

WARGER V. SHAUERS Court: USCA-8 Argument Date: 10/8/14 Author: J. Sotomayor Result: AFFIRMED

Granted: 3/3/14 Decided: 12/9/14

NC BOARD OF DENTAL EXAMINERS V. FTC Court: USCA-4 Granted: 3/3/14 Argument Date: 10/14/14 Decided: 2/25/15 Author: J. Kennedy Other: Alito (D) Result: AFFIRMED

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

CASES FOR ARGUMENT IN OCTOBER TERM 2014

13-550*

13-553

CFX

CFX

13-604

TIBBLE V. EDISON INTERNATIONAL Court: USCA-9 Argument Date: 2/24/15 Author: J. Breyer Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

Granted: 10/2/14 Decided: 5/18/15

ALABAMA DEPT. OF REVENUE V. CSX TRANSPORTATION Court: USCA-11 Granted: 7/1/14 Argument Date: 12/9/14 Decided: 3/4/15 Author: J. Scalia Other: Thomas (D) Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

CSY HEIEN V. NORTH CAROLINA Court: SC-NC Argument Date: 10/6/14 Author: Chief Justice Result: AFFIRMED

Granted: 4/21/14 Decided: 12/15/14 Other: Kagan (C); Sotomayor (D)

13-628

CFX

ZIVOTOFSKY V. KERRY, SEC. OF STATE Court: USCA-DC Granted: 4/21/14 Argument Date: 11/3/14 Decided: 6/8/15 Author: J. Kennedy Other: Breyer (C); Thomas (C/J/P, D/P) Chief Justice (D); Scalia (D) Result: AFFIRMED

13-684*

CFX

JESINOSKI V. COUNTRYWIDE HOME LOANS, INC. Court: USCA-8 Granted: 4/28/14 Argument Date: 11/4/14 Decided: 1/13/15 Author: J. Scalia Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

13-719

CFX

DART CHEROKEE BASIN OPERATING CO. V. OWENS Court: USCA-10 Granted: 4/7/14 Argument Date: 10/7/14 Decided: 12/15/14 Author: J. Ginsburg Other: Scalia (D); Thomas (D) Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

NOTE:

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

CASES FOR ARGUMENT IN OCTOBER TERM 2014

13-720

CFX

KIMBLE V. MARVEL ENTERTAINMENT, LLC Court: USCA-9 Granted: 12/12/14 Argument Date: 3/31/15 Decided: 6/22/15 Author: J. Kagan Other: Alito (D) Result: AFFIRMED

13-854

CFX

TEVA PHARMACEUTICALS USA, INC. V. SANDOZ, INC. Court: USCA-Fed. Granted: 3/31/14 Argument Date: 10/15/14 Decided: 1/20/15 Author: J. Breyer Other: Thomas (D) Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

13-894

CFX

DEPT. OF HOMELAND SECURITY V. MACLEAN Court: USCA-Fed. Granted: 5/19/14 Argument Date: 11/4/14 Decided: 1/21/15 Author: Chief Justice Other: Sotomayor (D) Result: AFFIRMED

13-895 ) 13-1138)

ATX ATX

ALABAMA LEGISLATIVE BLACK CAUCUS V. ALABAMA ALABAMA DEMOCRATIC CONFERENCE V. ALABAMA Court: USDC-Mid. Dist., AL Noted: 6/2/14 Argument Date: 11/12/14 Decided: 3/25/15 Author: J. Breyer Other: Scalia (D); Thomas (D) Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

13-896

CFX

COMMIL USA, LLC V. CISCO SYSTEMS, INC. Court: USCA-Fed. Granted: 12/5/14 (SB – no part) Argument Date: 3/31/15 Decided: 5/26/15 Author: J. Kennedy Other: Scalia (D) Result: VACATED AND REMANDED (SB – no part)

13-935

CFX

WELLNESS INT’L NETWORK V. SHARIF Court: USCA-7 Granted: 7/1/14 Argument Date: 1/14/15 Decided: 5/26/15 Author: J. Sotomayor Other: Alito (C/P, C/J); Chief Justice (D) Thomas (D) Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

NOTE:

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

CASES FOR ARGUMENT IN OCTOBER TERM 2014

13-975

CFX

T-MOBILE SOUTH, LLC V. CITY OF ROSWELL Court: USCA-11 Granted: 5/5/14 Argument Date: 11/10/14 Decided: 1/14/15 Author: J. Sotomayor Other: Alito (C); Chief Justice (D) Thomas (D) Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

13-983

CFY

ELONIS V. UNITED STATES Court: USCA-3 Argument Date: 12/1/14 Author: Chief Justice Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

Granted: 6/16/14 Decided: 6/1/15 Other: Alito (C/P, D/P); Thomas (D)

M&G POLYMERS USA V. TACKETT Court: USCA-6 Argument Date: 11/10/14 Author: J. Thomas Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

Granted: 5/5/14 Decided: 1/26/15 Other: Ginsburg (C)

13-1010*

13-1019*

13-1032*

13-1034

NOTE:

CFX

CFX

CFX

CFY

MACH MINING, LLC V. EEOC Court: USCA-7 Argument Date: 1/13/15 Author: J. Kagan Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

Granted: 6/30/14 Decided: 4/29/15

DIRECT MARKETING ASSN. V. BROHL Court: USCA-10 Argument Date: 12/8/14 Author: J. Thomas Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

Granted: 7/1/14 Decided: 3/3/15 Other: Kennedy (C); Ginsburg (C)

MELLOULI V. LYNCH, ATT’Y GEN. Court: USCA-8 Argument Date: 1/14/15 Author: J. Ginsburg Result: REVERSED

Granted: 6/30/14 Decided: 6/1/15 Other: Thomas (D)

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

CASES FOR ARGUMENT IN OCTOBER TERM 2014

13-1041)# 13-1052)

CFX CFX

PEREZ, SEC. OF LABOR V. MORTGAGE BANKERS ASSN. NICKOLS V. MORTGAGE BANKERS ASSN. Court: USCA-DC Granted: 6/16/14 Argument Date: 12/1/14 Decided: 3/9/15 Author: J. Sotomayor Other: Alito (C/P & C/J); Scalia (C/J) Thomas (C/J) Result: REVERSED

13-1074

CFX

UNITED STATES V. WONG Court: USCA-9 Granted: 6/30/14 Argument Date: 12/10/14 Decided: 4/22/15 Author: J. Kagan Other: Alito (D) Result together with No. 13-1075: AFFIRMED AND REMANDED

13-1075

CFX

UNITED STATES V. JUNE Court: USCA-9 Argument Date: 12/10/14

Granted: 6/30/14 Decided: 4/22/15 (See No. 13-1074)

13-1080#

CFX

DEPT. OF TRANSPORTATION V. ASSN. OF AM. RAILROADS Court: USCA-DC Granted: 6/23/14 Argument Date: 12/8/14 Decided: 3/9/15 Author: J. Kennedy Other: Alito (C); Thomas (C/J) Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

13-1174*

CFX

GELBOIM V. BANK OF AMERICA CORP. Court: USCA-2 Granted: 6/30/14 Argument Date: 12/9/14 Decided: 1/21/15 Author: J. Ginsburg Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

13-1175

CFX

CITY OF LOS ANGELES V. PATEL Court: USCA-9 Argument Date: 3/3/15 Author: J. Sotomayor Result: AFFIRMED

NOTE:

Granted: 10/20/14 Decided: 6/22/15 Other: Scalia (D); Alito (D)

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

CASES FOR ARGUMENT IN OCTOBER TERM 2014

13-1211*

CFX

HANA FINANCIAL, INC. V. HANA BANK Court: USCA-9 Granted: 6/23/14 Argument Date: 12/3/14 Decided: 1/21/15 Author: J. Sotomayor Result: AFFIRMED

13-1314

ATX

AZ STATE LEGISLATURE V. AZ INDEP. REDISTRICTING Court: USDC, Ariz. Juris Postponed: 10/2/14 Argument Date: 3/2/15 Decided: 6/29/15 Author: J. Ginsburg Other: Chief Justice (D); Scalia (D) Thomas (D) Result: AFFIRMED

13-1333*

CFX

COLEMAN V. TOLLEFSON Court: USCA-6 Argument Date: 2/23/15 Author: J. Breyer Result: AFFIRMED

13-1352#

CSY

OHIO V. CLARK Court: SC-OH Argument Date: 3/2/15 Author: J. Alito Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

Granted: 10/2/14 Decided: 5/18/15

Granted: 10/2/14 Decided: 6/18/15 Other: Scalia (C/J); Thomas (C/J)

13-1371

CFX

TX DEPT. HOUS. & COM. AFFAIRS V. INCLUSIVE COMMUNITIES PROJECT Court: USCA-5 Granted: 10/2/14 Argument Date: 1/21/15 Decided: 6/25/15 Author: J. Kennedy Other: Thomas (D); Alito (D) Result: AFFIRMED AND REMANDED

13-1402

CFX

KERRY, SEC. OF STATE V. DIN Court: USCA-9 Argument Date: 2/23/15 Author: J. Scalia Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

NOTE:

Granted: 10/2/14 Decided: 6/15/15 Other: Kennedy (C/J); Breyer (D)

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

CASES FOR ARGUMENT IN OCTOBER TERM 2014

13-1412

CFX

SAN FRANCISCO V. SHEEHAN Court: USCA-9 Granted: 11/25/14 (SB – no part) Argument Date: 3/23/15 Decided: 5/18/15 Author: J. Alito Other: Scalia (C/P, D/P) Result: CERTIORARI DISMISSED IN PART; REVERSED IN PART AND REMANDED (SB – no part)

13-1421)**# 14-163 )

CFX CFX

BANK OF AMERICA, N.A. V. CAULKETT BANK OF AMERICA, N.A. V. TOLEDO-CARDONA Court: USCA-11 Granted: 11/17/14 Argument Date: 3/24/15 Decided: 6/1/15 Author: J. Thomas Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

13-1428

CFH

DAVIS, ACTING WARDEN V. AYALA Court: USCA-9 Argument Date: 3/3/15 Author: J. Alito

Granted: 10/20/14 Decided: 6/18/15 Other: Kennedy (C); Thomas (C) Sotomayor (D)

Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

13-1433

CFH

13-1487*

13-1499

CFY

CSX

BRUMFIELD V. CAIN, WARDEN Court: USCA-5 Argument Date: 3/30/15 Author: J. Sotomayor Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

HENDERSON V. UNITED STATES Court: USCA-11 Argument Date: 2/24/15 Author: J. Kagan Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

WILLIAMS-YULEE V. FLORIDA BAR Court: SC-FL Argument Date: 1/20/15 Author: Chief Justice

Granted: 12/5/14 Decided: 6/18/15 Other: Thomas (D); Alito (D)

Granted: 10/20/14 Decided: 5/18/15

Granted: 10/2/14 Decided: 4/29/15 Other: Breyer (C); Ginsburg (C/P, C/J) Scalia (D); Kennedy (D); Alito (D)

Result: AFFIRMED

NOTE:

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

CASES FOR ARGUMENT IN OCTOBER TERM 2014

13-6827*

CFX

HOLT V. HOBBS, DIR., AR DOC Court: USCA-8 Argument Date: 10/7/14 Author: J. Alito

Granted: 3/3/14 Decided: 1/20/15 Other: Ginsburg (C) Sotomayor (C)

Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

13-7211

CFH

JENNINGS V. STEPHENS, DIR., TX DCJ Court: USCA-5 Granted: 3/24/14 Argument Date: 10/15/14 Decided: 1/14/15 Author: J. Scalia Other: Thomas (D) Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

13-7451

CFY

YATES V. UNITED STATES Court: USCA-11 Argument Date: 11/5/14 Author: J. Ginsburg Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

13-9026*

13-9972

CFY

CFY

WHITFIELD V. UNITED STATES Court: USCA-4 Argument Date: 12/2/14 Author: J. Scalia Result: AFFIRMED

RODRIGUEZ V. UNITED STATES Court: USCA-8 Argument Date: 1/21/15 Author: J. Ginsburg

Granted: 4/28/14 Decided: 2/25/15 Other: Alito (C/J); Kagan (D)

Granted: 6/23/14 Decided: 1/13/15

Granted: 10/2/14 Decided: 4/21/15 Other: Kennedy (D); Thomas (D) Alito (D)

Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

14-15

NOTE:

CFX

ARMSTRONG V. EXCEPTIONAL CHILD CENTER Court: USCA-9 Granted: 10/2/14 Argument Date: 1/20/15 Decided: 3/31/15 Author: J. Scalia Other: Breyer (C/P & C/J) Sotomayor (D) Result: REVERSED

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

CASES FOR ARGUMENT IN OCTOBER TERM 2014

14-46) 14-47) 14-49)

CFX CFX CFX

MICHIGAN V. EPA UTILITY AIR REGULATORY GROUP V. EPA NATIONAL MINING ASSOC. V. EPA Court: USCA-DC Granted: 11/25/14 Argument Date: 3/25/15 Decided: 6/29/15 Author: J. Scalia Other: Thomas (C); Kagan (D) Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

14-86

CFX

EEOC V. ABERCROMBIE & FITCH STORES Court: USCA-10 Granted: 10/2/14 Argument Date: 2/25/15 Decided: 6/1/15 Author: J. Scalia Other: Alito (C/J); Thomas (C/P, D/P) Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

14-103

CFX

BAKER BOTTS V. ASARCO Court: USCA-5 Argument Date: 2/25/15 Author: J. Thomas Result: AFFIRMED

Granted: 10/2/14 Decided: 6/15/15 Other: Sotomayor (C/P, C/J); Breyer (D)

KING V. BURWELL, SEC. OF H&HS Court: USCA-4 Argument Date: 3/4/15 Author: Chief Justice Result: AFFIRMED

Granted: 11/7/14 Decided: 6/25/15 Other: Scalia (D)

14-114

14-116*

14-144

NOTE:

CFX

CFX

CFX

BULLARD V. BLUE HILLS BANK Court: USCA-1 Argument Date: 4/1/15 Author: Chief Justice Result: AFFIRMED

Granted: 12/12/14 Decided: 5/4/15

WALKER V. TEXAS DIV., SONS OF CONFEDERATE VETS Court: USCA-5 Granted: 12/5/14 Argument Date: 3/23/15 Decided: 6/18/15 Author: J. Breyer Other: Alito (D) Result: REVERSED

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

CASES FOR ARGUMENT IN OCTOBER TERM 2014

14-185

14-275

CFX

CFX

MATA V. LYNCH, ATT’Y GEN. Court: USCA-5 Argument Date: 4/29/15 Author: J. Kagan Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

HORNE V. DEPT. OF AGRICULTURE Court: USCA-9 Argument Date: 4/22/15 Author: Chief Justice

Granted: 1/16/15 Decided: 6/15/15 Other: Thomas (D)

Granted: 1/16/15 Decided: 6/22/15 Other: Thomas (C); Breyer (C/P, D/P) Sotomayor (D)

Result: REVERSED

14-378#

14-400*

CFY

CFX

McFADDEN V. UNITED STATES Court: USCA-4 Argument Date: 4/21/15 Author: J. Thomas Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

HARRIS V. VIEGELAHN Court: USCA-5 Argument Date: 4/1/15 Author: J. Ginsburg Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

Granted: 1/16/15 Decided: 6/18/15 Other: Chief Justice (C/P, C/J)

Granted: 12/12/14 Decided: 5/18/15

14-556) 14-562) 14-571) 14-574)

CFX CFX CFX CFX

OBERGEFELL V. HODGES, DIR., OH DEPT. OF HEALTH TANCO V. HASLAM, GOV. OF TN DeBOER V. SNYDER, GOV. OF MI BOURKE V. BESHEAR, GOV. OF KY Court: USCA-6 Granted: 1/16/15 Argument Date: 4/28/15 Decided: 6/26/15 Author: J. Kennedy Other: Chief Justice (D); Thomas (D) Alito (D) Result: REVERSED

14-6368

CFX

KINGSLEY V. HENDRICKSON Court: USCA-7 Argument Date: 4/27/15 Author: J. Breyer Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

NOTE:

Granted: 1/16/15 Decided: 6/22/15 Other: Scalia (D); Alito (D)

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

CASES FOR ARGUMENT IN OCTOBER TERM 2014

14-7955

CFX

GLOSSIP V. GROSS Court: USCA-10 Argument Date: 4/29/15 Author: J. Alito

Granted: 1/23/15 Decided: 6/29/15 Other: Scalia (C); Thomas (C) Breyer (D); Sotomayor (D)

Result: AFFIRMED

NOTE: 13-640

CFX

PUBLIC EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT SYS. OF MS V. INDYMAC MBS, INC. Court: USCA-2 Granted: 3/10/14 Argument Date: 10/6/14 Order: 9/29/14 Result: DISMISSED AS IMPROVIDENTLY GRANTED

13-7120

CFY

JOHNSON V. UNITED STATES Court: USCA-8 Granted: 4/21/14 Argument Date: 11/5/14 Order: 1/9/15 – restored to calendar for reargument Reargument Date: 4/20/15 Decided: 6/26/15 Author: J. Scalia Other: Kennedy (C/J); Thomas (C/J) Alito (D) Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

13-10400

CFX

CHEN V. MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL OF BALTIMORE Court: USCA-4 Granted: 11/7/14 Order: 1/9/15 Result: DISMISSED

14-6381

CSH

TOCA V. LOUISIANA Court: SC-LA Order: 2/3/15 Result: DISMISSED – Rule 46

NOTE:

Granted: 12/12/14

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

CASES FOR ARGUMENT IN OCTOBER TERM 2014

No. of Cases made available for Argument (Hours): 78 (72.1) No. of Cases Argued (Hours): 75 (69.1) No. of Cases Reargued (Hours): 1 (1) No. of Cases Disposed of (Hours): 78 (72.1) DISPOSED OF WITH ARGUMENT: By Signed Opinion/Judgment – 75 (66.1)

By Per Curiam Opinion –

Dismissed/Other –

DISPOSED OF WITHOUT ARGUMENT: By Signed Opinion/Judgment -

By Per Curiam Opinion –

No. of Opinions: 66 (Signed – 66; Per Curiam – )

CASE CODE KEY 

First Letter = Jurisdictional Grounds (ex. 13-100 CSX)

C - Certiorari A - Appeal Q - Certified Question  S F T M O 

Second Letter = Court Below (ex. 13-100 CSX) -

State U.S. Court of Appeals Three-Judge District Court U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces Other Court Third Letter = Nature of Case (ex. 13-100 CSX)

X - Civil Y - Criminal H - Habeas Corpus or other collateral attack

NOTE:

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

Dismissed/Other – 3 (3)