Google's Opening Statement - SB Nation [PDF]

  
 
 










  














 












 
  







  
 
































  














 












 
  







  
 



























The Java programming language is open and free for anyone to use.




  

  


"




  
 
 


 

 
  



 !
 


 


 




 


 

 





  "





Ellison Deposition., p 47:5-10 #


The names of the various items appearing in the disputed API package specifications, such as names of API files, packages, classes, and methods, are not protected.





 

  
 






 


 


 











 








   








   


 


 


  


   


  




  


 


    


 


 


   


 


  


 


 


 





 


 





  






 


!


 

 
 








%"%$ %$$"


%" "



%""$"



&$""& %$$"



&$""&%$ %$$"



"""& "



"""&"$"



$ %$$"



$%$ %$$"







#" $"



 %$$"



%$ %$$"



 "##



 "



"$"



$" %$$"



$"%$ %$$"



$" "



$""$"



 %$$"



 %$$" "



 %" %$$"



 %" "



$ %$$"



$ %$$"($



$%$ %$$"



$%$ %$$"( %$



$$"##



$$"



%$ %$$"



%$ %$$""$"



  %$$"



 %$ %$$"



  "



 "$"



"$$"



"$"$"



%# %$$"



%# "



##



"



!% %$$"



"' "##



$"'"



$"%" %$$"



$" "



$""$"

"$"


*


 

 
  












































#









 










 










"















  




 




 "!




 "























































 











 





 




 





 











 
















 





 







 












$


 
  



http://download.oracle.com/javase/6/docs/api/java/lang/package-summary.html (as of September 26, 2011) 


  





TX 0980 


  
 
  



'
 
 
#


)

&


&








 '

 &
! &
 !&


'





 &
 
&




 
&

"
&


 
"
 
&

 
"
 
'
'
'
$


 




 



"$
(
"

  

&
$
"&
 &
! &
  &

')



Mitchell Deposition., p. 121:1-10 *+





 


%
!
$


.
+


&'

%
%
 )

+
*


&

 *
&
&$
'
%

$+
$
&$



& 

$ "

%

'
*

'
$"
& 

$ 
&


$'
!+

$
$
& 
,,
'$
&*
'$
$

$ "

$

 

 
*
$
'$
&$-




' 
& 
+.


Reinhold Deposition., p. 115:7-17 /0












Open source based on Java programming language, including Java language APIs

1998 



 


Apache Harmony Open source based on Java programming language, including Java language APIs

2005





 
  
 


May 9, 2007:

"Jonathan Schwartz, CEO at Sun, said in a press conference,  
 
 




'there is no reason that Apache cannot ship Harmony today….'"

TX2341








 


Apache Harmony

Lotus Notes, SameTime, Symphony, and Expeditor








  














 












 
  







  
 
































  

   




Gmail

Google Maps

Google search 


 




  








 

  










 

  

  


   






 
 



 









 


 

  

 






 
 







 





 
  


Applications


Handset Manufacturers


Developers


Android 






 
"


   

&
,**1%



 

 


,**2%


 

$
,**1%






 $
,**.%

 



 
,**2%




 

#$



!&
,**0%


"



'
,**.

,**1%



 

,**.


,**/
  
,**.

',**/%




 




!&
,**2%







!


   





,**0



,*+*%






,**1


,**2


,*+*


  
,*+*%
" 

,-



 
 

 

  


 



TX 205 


 
 






  
  






  
  









  
  






  
  






  
  






  
  


 





high performance graphics





  
  





web browser engine





  
  


 


  


rich audio and video





  
  






  
  






  
  


 
  









 



 
  



37 Java API Packages







 



 
  



37 Java API Packages




Applications


Application Developer 


Application Developer 


API Price: High to Low

Sort

max()



sort by price

Application Developer 




   
 

  
 
API

Source Code Implementation

choose greater of two numbers

tells the computer what to do

max()



Android 




   
 

  
 
API

Source Code Implementation

choose greater of two numbers

tells the computer what to do

max()



GNU Classpath 0.9.8 




   
 

  
 
API

Source Code Implementation

choose greater of two numbers

tells the computer what to do

max()



OpenJDK 6







 
  


 

   
java.lang.Math.max() "+,

  

 


"+
&

,
-









+
$3
,
 
'


**












++
33
0)0,
//
+
33
0)0,












//
+) +,
33
! ,,
-












 
'








.








 
+
43
,
%

(
'




.


max()



  
  
 


12


  
   





   
java.lang.Math.max() "+,

  



max()


 


"+
&

,
-









+
$4
,
 
'


**












++
44
1)1,
//
+
44
1)1,












//
+) +,
44
! ,,
-












 
'








.








 
+
54
,
%

(
'




.



  
  
 
Application Developer 23




   

  


max()


Max(


java.lang.Math.max()






   

  


java.lang.Math.max() java.io.FileInputStream.read()

read()
Max

(







   

  


max()


Max(


java.lang.Math.max() package

class

method




 
 
 !



 

" #

  


 

  






TX 2392  
 
 


 
 





 
" 


 
 

%!&
!  

# $




!  
# $






TX 2392  
 
 


 
 




   

 







 





 


 










 

  





   

 






 



  









 



 
 










  














 












 
  







  
 



























 


  
  
 


 
 



 
 


TX 2352 


 


  
  
 


 
 



 
 


TX 2352 





 

 

  



 
 



 
 


TX 2356 (OAGOOGLE0004646342)






 






 


'
#
 


  
 #
#

 % 
  #
#
  
  #
 

  #

 


 $

 &






  $'


 !

 



TX 2041 at GOOGLE-00-00001732-33

*)







 
  
 


%



+
*


'
!'


#
 !'
!'
%!
#'
!'
" 


"



" '
# 

"%
$ (
!
#'
#*

!'

!
"%
!

 (
)

#






"
" '





!


(+


 



TX 2041 at GOOGLE-00-00001732-33

.-







  














 












 
  







  
 
































 






  


TX 2200

TX 2199

TX 2969 


 



 





 





 

 

 



TX 02042 


 
 
 


 


TX 2044 at OAGOOGLE0006624738 



 



 


 

  
 




TX 2044 at OAGOOGLE0006624759





 
  
 











 
  



Ellison Deposition., p. 83:16-25