here - Harvard Magazine

5 downloads 265 Views 189KB Size Report
Jun 4, 2018 - ... this proposed policy change and the long-term damage it will do to our health, our communities, and ou
    !( "(&( #$% &(

%%'%&&%( (

(    (

$( %%'%&&%(   (

F=%N N N

4%N>=>B!":%N#>EENBF6EEN $;6=6DEB!E>BN>&NE4%N=H6B>=;%=E!:NB>E%#E6>=N3%=#KN

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



6$R R?&R R 7$;E7RC$!?C#DR M8DE8>6R;KRAE8$>ER!?>0#$>E8;8ENRDE>#C#DR>#R=?DER8>&?C=$#!?>D$>ER6C$$P =$>EDR2CRC$D$C!7RACE8!8A>EDR;;RAC?E$!ERAE8$>EDR8#$>E8E8$DR NRC$DEC8!E8>6R!!$DDRE?RE7$8CRAC8JE$R 8>1C=E8?>R C$BH$>E;NRE7?H67R>?ER8>R$J$CNR!D$R>?>N=8O8>6R>#R#$8#$>E858>6R8>1C=E8?>R!EDR DR>R$DD$>E8;RD+6HC#R1CRAE8$>ERAC8J!NR $;8>!$RHA?>RDEH#8$DR$J$>RK7$>RE7$NR8>!;H#$RAC8JE$R 7$;E7R#ERE7ER!>>?ER $RC$;$D$#RE?RE7$RAH ;8!R8DR>?ER>R$M$C!8D$R8>RD$!C$ERD!8$>"$R8ER8DRC$DA?>D8 ;$R D!8$>!$R 7$RAC?A?D$#RCH;$RK8E7R8EDRAC?78 8E8?>R68>DERRC$;8>!$R?>R>NRDEH#NRK7$C$RA$CD?>;;NR 8#$>E80 ;$R#ER!>>?ER $R=#$RAH ;8!R$,$!E8J$;NR#8DBH;80$DRE7$R $DERJ8; ;$RD!8$>!$R3?=RHD$R8>R E7$RC$6H;E?CNRAC?!$DDR 7$R;>#=C:RCJC#R8MR8E8$DRDEH#NR8DR?>$RDH!7R$M=A;$R H ;8D7$#R8>R

R8MR8E8$DR C$J$;$#RRDEC?>6R;8>:R $EL$$>R8CRA?;;HE8?>R>#R;8&$R$MA$!E>!NR 7$RDEH#NR>#R?E7$CDRE7ER1;P ;?K$#RD$CJ$#RDRE7$R D8DR1CR*$#$C;RC$6H;E8?>DRE7ER7J$RC$#H!$#R0>$RACE8!H;E$R=EE$CR8>RE7$R 8CRK$R C$E7$R>#R;?>6E$C=R>;ND$DRAH ;8D7$#RD8>!$RE7$D$RC$6H;E8?>DRK$C$R8=A;$=$>E$#R 8>#8!E$RE7ERE7$R;?>6E$C=R7$;E7R>#R$!?>?=8!R $>$0EDR7J$R $$>RC$=C: ;$R $DA8E$RE7$D$R#$=?>DECE$#R $>$0EDR8MR8E8$DR7DRC$A$E$#;NR $$>R!8E$#RDR>R$M=A;$R?'R D$!C$ERD!8$>!$RR!7C6$RE7ER8EDRD!8$>!$R!>>?ER $RECHDE$#R $!HD$RD?=$R?'RE7$RH>#$C;N8>6R#ER 8DR>?ERJ8; ;$R1CRAH ;8!RD!CHE8>NR CJC#R7DRD7C$#RD86>80!>ER8>1C=E8?>R>#R!??A$CE$#R $>E8C$;NR8>RR4;;R8>#$A$>#$>ERC$>;ND8DR?&RE7$R#ER NRE7$R$;E7R-$!EDR>DE8EHE$RRK78!7R !?>0C=$#RE7$RJ;8#8ENR?&RE7$R0>#8>6DR 7C?H67RE7ERAC?!$DDR>#RD8>!$RCJC#R7DRAC?E$!E$#RE7$R A$CD?>;R7$;E7R8>1C=E8?>R>#R8#$>E8ENR?&RDEH#NRACE8!8A>EDRK7?RK$C$R6HC>E$$#R!?>0#$>E8;8GR 7ER!?==8E=$>ERE?R!?>0#$>E8;8ENR8DR>$!$DDCNR&@CR!?>EC!EH;R>#R;$6;RC$D?>DRE?R $RDHC$R HER E8;RC$D$C!7RJ?;H>E$$CDRE7ERCJC#RK8;;R;KNDRAC?E$!ERE7$8CRAC8JE$R7$;E7R 8>&@C=E8?>R 'R>?ER8>#8J8#H;DR=NR $R#8DDH#$#R3?=RACE8!8AE8>6R8>R>$KRDEH#8$DR>#RE7$RBH;8GR ?&R4EHC$RD!8$>!$RK?H;#RDH.$CR $N?>#RE7$RRC$>;ND8DRE7$R0>#8>6DR?&R8MR8E8$DR7J$R $$>RC$A;8!E$#R>H=$C?HDRE8=$DR 8>R=>NR8>#$A$>#$>ERDEH#8$DRHD8>6R#8-$C$>ERDEH#NR#$D86>DR;C6$CR>H= $CDR?&R$>C?;;$$DR C?#$CR 6$?6CA78!;R#8DEC8 HE8?>DR!C?DDR=H;E8A;$RC$68?>DR?'RE7$RK?C;#R>#R8>!C$D8>6;NRD7CAR>;NE8!;R E??;DR 7$R>H= $CR?&RDFH#8$DRC$A;8!E8>6R8MR8E8$DR?C868>;R0>#8>6DR#$=?>DE CE$RE7$RD?H>#>$DDR?&R E7$RD!8$>E80!RAC?!$DDR>#R7J$R$DE ;8D7$#R>R$ME$>D8J$R1H>#E8?>R?&R;8E$CEHC$RK7?D$R!?>!;HD8?>DR C$R9HDERDR8=A?CE>ERE?RE7$RK$867ER?&R$J8#$>!$RDR8MR8E8$DR8ED$;(R ?R!;;RQI!7RD!8$>!$RD$!C$ER8DRE?R =8DC$AC$D$>ERE7$RD!8$>E80!RAC?!$DDR $A;8!E8?>R?)C$DH;EDRHD8>6R#8,$C$>ER#ER>?ERC$J$;E8?>R?&R A$CD?>;;NR8#$>E80 ;$R7$;E7R#ER8DRE7$RDEC$>6E7R NRK78!7RK$RD7?H;#R=$DHC$R?HCRD!8$>!$R 7$RK$;;$DE ;8D7$#R;8>:R $EK$$>R8CRBH;8GR>#R;8'%R$MA$!E>!NR8DR HER?>$R$M=A;$R?'R!C8E8!;R AH ;8!R7$;E7R8>1C=E8?>RE7ER!?H;#R $R1C!$#R?HER?'RA?;8!NR&@C=E8?>R NRE78DRCH;$R !8$>!$R8DR>?ER H>#$CE:$>RD?;$;NR1CRE7$R9?NR?'R:>?K8>6R8ER8DR>R$/?CERE?R8=AC?J$R?HCD$;J$DR?HCR;8J$DR>#R?HCR K?C;#R RHC6$RN?HRE?RC$9$!ERE78DRAC?A?D$#RA?;8!NR!7>6$R>#RE7$R;?>6E$C=R#=6$R8ERK8;;R#?RE?R?HCR 7$;E7R?HCR!?==H>8E8$DR>#R?HCR>E8?>R 8>!$C$;NR

C$KR8;A8>RHDER !!R

$?=8R?R