Mediating Populism - Demos

A copy of the work or link to its use online is sent to Demos. ... The internet's increasing function as a source of political news means that traditional media ..... Like Brexit in the UK, the migration crisis has been seen as a key test for the German media ..... news gathering, ameliorating the speed at which journalists can contact ...
3MB Sizes 12 Downloads 129 Views
Mediating Populism

Sophie Gaston and

Peter Harrison-Evans

 

Open  Access.  Some  rights  reserved.  

As  the  publisher  of  this  work,  Demos  wants  to  encourage  the  circulation  of  our     work  as  widely  as  possible  while  retaining  the  copyright.  We  therefore  have  an  open     access  policy  which  enables  anyone  to  access  our  content  online  without  charge.   Anyone  can  download,  save,  perform  or  distribute  this  work  in  any  format,  including     translation,  without  written  permission.  This  is  subject  to  the  terms  of  the  Demos     licence  found  at  the  back  of  this  publication.  Its  main  conditions  are:     ·∙   Demos  and  the  author(s)  are  credited   ·∙   This  summary  and  the  address  www.demos.co.uk  are  displayed   ·∙   The  text  is  not  altered  and  is  used  in  full   ·∙   The  work  is  not  resold   ·∙   A  copy  of  the  work  or  link  to  its  use  online  is  sent  to  Demos.     You  are  welcome  to  ask  for  permission  to  use  this  work  for  purposes  other  than  those     covered  by  the  licence.  Demos  gratefully  acknowledges  the  work  of  Creative  Commons     in  inspiring  our  approach  to  copyright.  To  find  out  more  go  to  www.creativecommons.org         Published  by  Demos,  March  2018   ©  Demos.  Some  rights  reserved.   Demos   2-­‐3  Mill  Street   London  SE1  2BD   T:  020  7367  4200   [email protected]   www.demos.co.uk  

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors would firstly like to recognise the hugely valuable contribution of the journalists, editors and producers who gave their time to this project, and who trusted us with their candid and honest reflections. Secondly, we gratefully acknowledge the Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung in supporting the research and launch events associated with this project. We are also hugely appreciative of Das Progressive Zentrum for their case study, and for being such enthusiastic and enjoyable research partners. We humbly thank Opinium Research, for their superior research assistance with the quantitative polling. Finally, we thank our colleagues, in particular the wonderful Sacha Hilhorst and Caitlin Lambert, in bringing this to publication. As ever, any mistakes or omissions are the authors’ own.

 

CONTENTS Executive Summary

1

Introduction

7

1 Mediating Populism in Britain

10

2 The German Media’s Response to Populism

48

3 Comparative Analysis: British and German Media

73

4 Conclusions and Ways Forward

78

References

85

FOREWORD The internet’s increasing function as a source of political news means that traditional media now operate in a much more convoluted and contested environment. Citizens are overwhelmed with information from a wide variety of sources, much of it lacking ratified credibility or even actively promoting misinformation. At the same time, media organisations must navigate the rise of populist leaders and their divisive or potentially dangerous views - many of whom share natural affinities with media conventions favouring conflict, strong personalities and dynamism. In light of both of these trends, there is a greater need than ever for the media to be more exacting and robust, and to uphold its traditional gatekeeping role, and yet its capacity to do so appears to be more constrained than ever. Over the past two years, as Western politics has reeled from a series of seismic shocks, there has been a surge in the scrutiny paid to social media platforms for their responsibility in opening the information marketplace to new actors with different practices and standards. While the digital age has profoundly reshaped the media environment and the relationships between outlets and audiences, citizens continue to largely consume content from traditional providers. Considerably less atte