Gros, Harvard Law School ex aequo Lipton, Universidad de San Andrés. 7. Pinto, University of Warsaw ex ..... advance to
SKADDEN ARPS FDI MOOT
2017
Oral Rounds Suffolk University Law School 1. Jennings, National Law School of India University 2. Trindade, Charles University 3. Ugon, Lomonosov Moscow State University 4. Gaja, University of International Business and Economics 5. Gros, Harvard Law School ex aequo Lipton, Universidad de San Andrés 7. Pinto, University of Warsaw ex aequo Winiarski, Murdoch University The winner of the Global Orals was awarded the Skadden Arps Trophy and the Investor State Law Guide Prize. Claimant Memorials* 1. Hsu, Paris Bar School 2. Baxter, University of Halle-Wittenberg 3. Fabela, Federal University Rio Grande do Sul Respondent Memorials* 1. Skotnikov, National University of Advanced Legal Studies 2. Gaja, University of International Business and Economics 3. Tomka, University of Ottawa The top 6 memorials will be published in the TDM Journal. *A table of all written results is available at the end of the document. Highest Ranked Teams Alias
University Name
Claimant Respondent
1. Tomka
University of Ottawa, Faculty of Law
256.52
258.33 885.2 1400.05
2. Bravo
Universidad de Buenos Aires
240.22
252.08 853.2
3. Guerrero
De La Salle University, College of Law
227.26
241.67 866.2 1335.13
4. Trindade
Charles University
238.04
250 846.2 1334.24
5. Winiarski
Murdoch University, School of Law
216.30
241.67 874.2 1332.17
6. Jennings
National Law School of India University
210.87
257.29 856.2 1324.36
7. Gaja
University of International Business and Economics
258.70
263.54 793.2 1315.44
8. Hsu
Paris Bar School
280.43
219.79 813.2 1313.42
9. Alfaro
MGIMO-University
218.48
234.38 859.2 1312.06
10. Gros
Harvard Law School
261.96
211.46 824.2 1297.62
11. Keith
National Law University Jodhpur
243.48
226.04 825.2 1294.72
12. Skotnikov
National University of Advanced Legal Studies
196.74
288.54 804.2 1289.48
13. Pinto
University of Warsaw
215.22
211.46 860.2 1286.88
14. Baxter
University of Halle-Wittenberg
264.22
212.50 808.2 1284.92
15. Rau
Amity Law School, Delhi, GGSIPU
234.78
217.71 831.2 1283.69
16. Higgins
Universitas Pelita Harapan
214.13
226.04 829.2 1269.37
17. Ugon
Lomonosov Moscow State University
225
216.67 819.2 1260.87
-1-
OralZ
Total 1345.5
18. Amor
Universitas Gadjah Mada
228.26
256.52 769.2 1253.98
19. Lipton
Universidad de San Andrés
207.52
202.08 836.2 1245.80
20. Fabela
Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul
263.04
221.88 759.2 1244.12
21. Armand
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
194.57
222.92 813.2 1230.69
22. Khan
Universidade de São Paulo
247.83
195.83 781.2 1224.86
23. Xue
Jagiellonian University
192.39
212.5 796.2 1201.09
24. Tanaka
Faculty of Law, Universiti Teknologi MARA
235.87
195.83 762.2 1193.90
25. Rivero
Suffolk University Law School
253.26
179.17 759.2 1191.63
26. Hackworth Gujarat National Law University, Gandhinagar
207.61
202.86 777.2 1187.67
27. Pathak
The University of Hong Kong, Faculty of Law
192.39
222.92 769.2 1184.51
28. Camara
Pontifical Catholic University of Rio Grande do Sul
185.87
187.50 799.2 1172.57
29. Aguilar
Pepperdine University School of Law
232.61
163.54 769.2 1165.35
30. Simma
King's College London
208.70
178.13 776.2 1163.03
31. McNair
Far Eastern University, Institute of Law
185.96
175 793.2 1154.16
32. Crawford
FGV São Paulo Law School
185.87
175 790.2 1151.07
33. Castro
Universidad del Rosario
183.70
189.58 777.2 1150.48
34. Jessup
Pontifical Catholic of São Paulo
153.35
195.57 788.2 1137.12
35. Visscher
Saint Petersburg State University
217.39
161.46 755.2 1134.05
36. Waldock
Carlos III University
182.61
227.08 706.2 1115.89
37. Klaestad
Tsinghua University, School of Law
185.87
201.04 726.2 1113.11
38. Mo
University of Houston Law Center
185.87
166.67 745.2 1097.74
39. Yusuf
University of Miami, School of Law
193.48
150 741.2 1084.68
40. Elias
Externado University of Colombia
216.3
183.33 684.2 1083.83
41. Robinson
Kenya School of Law
156.52
183.33 741.2 1081.05
42. Carneiro
ELTE Law School
252.17
160.42 665.2 1077.79
43. Tarassov
University of Barcelona, IELPO LL.M.
185.87
150 726.2 1062.07
44. Ruda
University of Passau
215.22
172.92 657.2 1045.34
45. Lachs
Istanbul Sehir University
219.57
153.13 655.2 1027.90
46. Shi
National University of Lesotho
167.39
150 699.2 1016.59
47. Ladreit
Haramaya University College of Law
179.35
159.38 640.2
978.93
48. Koretsky
Masaryk University
156.52
154.17 642.2
952.89
49. Singh*
Russian State University of Justice
208.70
210.42
N/A
419.12
50. Lacharriere* Diplomatic Academy of Viet Nam
193.48
204.17
N/A
397.65
51. Ago*
NEA - Northern Center of Arbitration Studies
189.13
161.46
N/A
350.59
52. Koroma*
African Nazarene University
165.22
168.75
N/A
333.97
* Teams not at the Global Oral Finals but participating in the written phase of the competition. The Highest Ranked Team was awarded the Baker & McKenzie Prize as well as of Investor State Law Guide Prize. The second and third highest ranked teams each received a copy of the Kluwer publication “Arbitral Awards as Investments: Treaty Interpretation and the Dynamics of International Investment Law”. -2-
Top 50 Advocates Advodate
Team Alias
ZScore
1. Jolene Hansell*
Tomka
238.36
2. Julia Therese Pineda
Guerrero
237.36
3. Edwin Roberto Concepcion
Guerrero
236.36
4. Agata Kruczyk
Pinto
229.36
5. Tanesha Singh
Rau
228.36
6. Angelica Maria Perdomo Luna
Castro
225.36
Andrew Shinnick
Winiarski
225.36
Angeliki Kolokotsa
Armand
225.36
9. María Pía Alais
Lipton
223.36
10. Manika Sadarangani
Higgins
222.36
Bravo
222.36
12. Georgy Obolentsev
Alfaro
220.36
13. Aubrey Xiong
Gaja
219.36
Nikola Klimova
Trindade
219.36
Chaitali Wadhwa
Rau
219.36
Winiarski
218.36
Grace Walia
Higgins
218.36
18. Andrea Carbone
Simma
217.36
Jennings
217.36
20. Mathea Schmitt
Baxter
216.36
21. Erik Shum
Tomka
215.36
Tomka
215.36
Xue
212.36
Keith
212.36
Amor
211.36
Gros
211.36
Jennings
210.36
Sanjana Rao
Keith
210.36
Helena Svandova
Trindade
210.36
Klaestad
209.36
Aleksandra Samsonova
Alfaro
209.36
Ece Akincibay
Hsu
209.36
Skotnikov
208.36
Crawford
208.36
Lipton
206.36
Ugon
206.36
Juan Ignacio Gonzalez Mayer
16. Marche Bantum
Aditya Mehta
Mohiminol Khandaker 23. Maria Skwara Amrita Shivaprasad 25. Naila Gadiza Andriana Sjarif Christian Vandergeest 27. Prakshal Jain
30. Yueran Zhao
33. Pranay Prakash Gabriela Du Plessis 35. Juan Ignacio Amado Aranda Aglaya Melnik
-3-
Kevin Reddington
Aguilar
206.36
Keith
205.36
Jessup
205.36
Crawford
204.36
Andréa Bodanese
Camara
204.36
Krzysztof Wasiewicz
Pinto
204.36
Joshua Scoles
Winiarski
204.36
Li Pan
Gros
204.36
Hackworth
203.36
Hsu
203.36
Amor
202.36
Sofya Cherkasova
Ugon
202.36
Evgenii Bulatov
Visscher
202.36
Ramya Ramachanderan
Yusuf
202.36
38. Sneha Singh Deborah Magnoni 40. Gabriella Sorrilha
45. Garima Kedia Daria Pavlyuchok 47. Abigail Tabitha Annisa Soemarko
*Top Advocate is the winner of the Thomas Wälde Award for Best Advocate and the Manuela Béltran Award for the Best Woman Advocate Cash Prize sponsored by José Manuel Álvarez Zárate, recipient of the Kluwer publication “ICSID after 50 Years” and an ICSID Review Subscription. Best Advocate of the Final Match Jennings Aditya Mehta Recipient of the Kluwer publication “The First 50 Years of ICSID” and ICSID Review Subscription. Individual Match Results, Preliminary Rounds– sorted by Claimant Team C_Alias
C_mem1
C_Oralsum
C_Total
R_Alias
R_mem1
R_Oralsum
R_Total
Ago
189.13
ex parte
Simma
178.13
211
255.53
Ago
189.13
ex parte
Lipton
202.08
260
310.52
Aguilar
232.61
231
289.15
Pinto
211.46
251
303.87
Aguilar
232.61
238
296.15
Skotnikov
288.54
236
308.14
Alfaro
218.48
261
315.62
Tarassov
150
232
269.50
Alfaro
218.48
261
315.62
Klaestad
201.04
255
305.26
Amor
228.26
196
253.07
Guerrero
241.67
222
282.42
Amor
228.26
244
301.07
Ladreit
159.38
223
262.85
Armand
194.57
253
301.64
Gros
211.46
252
304.87
Armand
194.57
262
310.64
Robinson
183.33
251
296.83
Baxter
264.22
232
298.06
Jessup
195.57
238
286.89
Baxter
264.22
271
337.06
Lachs
153.13
206
244.28
Bravo
240.22
268
328.06
Jennings
257.29
253
317.32
Bravo
240.22
235
295.06
Carneiro
160.42
197
237.11
Camara
185.87
255
301.4675
Elias
183.33
224
269.83
Camara
185.87
231
277.4675
Trindade
250
247
309.50
1
Claimant/Respondent Memorial Scores were weighted (Cmem or Rmem * 0.25) into each match to determine the points. -4-
Carneiro
252.17
220
283.04
Jennings
257.29
263
327.32
Carneiro
252.17
215
278.04
Mo
166.67
237
278.67
Castro
183.7
221
266.93
Ruda
172.92
199
242.23
Castro
183.7
242
287.93
Gaja
263.54
219
284.89
Crawford
185.87
236
282.47
Pathak
222.92
246
301.73
Crawford
185.87
262
308.47
Koretsky
154.17
226
264.54
Elias
216.3
227
281.08
Rivero
179.17
198
242.79
Elias
216.3
212
266.08
Trindade
250
253
315.50
Fabela
263.04
234
299.76
Gros
211.46
252
304.87
Fabela
263.04
245
310.76
Armand
222.92
253
308.73
Gaja
258.7
247
311.68
Rau
217.71
235
289.43
Gaja
258.7
261
325.68
Khan
195.83
234
282.96
Gros
261.96
238
303.49
Robinson
183.33
234
279.83
Gros
261.96
267
332.49
McNair
175
255
298.75
Guerrero
227.26
283
339.82
Ladreit
159.38
205
244.85
Guerrero
227.26
292
348.82
Koretsky
154.17
203
241.54
Hackworth
207.61
243
294.90
Armand
222.92
230
285.73
Hackworth
207.61
229
280.90
Fabela
221.88
225
280.47
Higgins
214.13
251
304.53
Tarassov
150
221
258.50
Higgins
214.13
282
335.53
Alfaro
234.38
265
323.60
Hsu
280.43
258
328.11
Winiarski
241.67
264
324.42
Hsu
280.43
247
317.11
Tanaka
195.83
242
290.96
Jennings
210.87
266
318.72
Mo
166.67
246
287.67
Jennings
210.87
259
311.72
Visscher
161.46
258
298.37
Jessup
153.35
251
289.34
Lachs
153.13
195
233.28
Jessup
153.35
239
277.34
Aguilar
163.54
268
308.89
Keith
243.48
230
290.87
Shi
150
208
245.50
Keith
243.48
268
328.87
Camara
187.5
240
286.88
Khan
247.83
252
313.96
Rau
217.71
232
286.43
Khan
247.83
237
298.96
Yusuf
150
237
274.50
Klaestad
185.87
206
252.47
Xue
212.5
223
276.13
Klaestad
185.87
211
257.47
Tomka
258.33
270
334.58
Koretsky
156.52
214
253.13
Amor
256.52
269
333.13
Koretsky
156.52
184
223.13
Pathak
222.92
233
288.73
Lachs
219.57
191
245.89
Aguilar
163.54
217
257.89
Lachs
219.57
248
302.89
Skotnikov
288.54
259
331.14
Ladreit
179.35
174
218.84
Crawford
175
225
268.75
Ladreit
179.35
223
267.84
Ugon
216.67
272
326.17
Lipton
207.52
243
294.88
Tanaka
195.83
226
274.96
Lipton
207.52
247
298.88
Hsu
219.79
234
288.95
-5-
McNair
185.96
231
277.49
Hackworth
202.86
254
304.72
McNair
185.96
252
298.49
Fabela
221.88
240
295.47
Mo
185.87
215
261.47
Visscher
161.46
205
245.37
Mo
185.87
232
278.47
Waldock
227.08
230
286.77
Pathak
192.39
223
271.10
Ugon
216.67
225
279.17
Pathak
192.39
252
300.10
Amor
256.52
245
309.13
Pinto
215.22
265
318.81
Baxter
212.5
252
305.13
Pinto
215.22
270
323.81
Jessup
195.57
245
293.89
Rau
234.78
285
343.70
Castro
189.58
279
326.40
Rau
234.78
264
322.70
Yusuf
150
246
283.50
Rivero
253.26
244
307.32
Keith
226.04
251
307.51
Rivero
253.26
231
294.32
Shi
150
222
259.50
Robinson
156.52
233
272.13
McNair
175
240
283.75
Robinson
156.52
208
247.13
Hackworth
202.86
236
286.72
Ruda
215.22
208
261.81
Khan
195.83
243
291.96
Ruda
215.22
246
299.81
Gaja
263.54
251
316.89
Shi
167.39
242
283.85
Camara
187.5
258
304.88
Shi
167.39
212
253.85
Elias
183.33
206
251.83
Simma
208.7
232
284.18
Lipton
202.08
271
321.52
Simma
208.7
262
314.18
Hsu
219.79
259
313.95
Skotnikov
196.74
264
313.19
Baxter
212.5
238
291.13
Skotnikov
196.74
230
279.19
Pinto
211.46
259
311.87
Tanaka
235.87
250
308.97
Ago
161.46
Tanaka
235.87
229
287.97
Winiarski
241.67
281
341.42
Tarassov
185.87
229
275.47
Klaestad
201.04
239
289.26
Tarassov
185.87
229
275.47
Xue
212.5
246
299.13
Tomka
256.52
251
315.13
Alfaro
234.38
257
315.60
Tomka
256.52
264
328.13
Higgins
226.04
226
282.51
Trindade
238.04
264
323.51
Keith
226.04
261
317.51
Trindade
238.04
267
326.51
Rivero
179.17
271
315.79
Ugon
225
233
289.25
Guerrero
241.67
254
314.42
Ugon
225
274
330.25
Crawford
175
252
295.75
Visscher
217.39
222
276.35
Waldock
227.08
203
259.77
Visscher
217.39
255
309.35
Bravo
252.08
272
335.02
Waldock
182.61
211
256.66
Carneiro
160.42
218
258.11
Waldock
182.61
247
292.66
Bravo
252.08
263
326.02
Winiarski
216.3
259
313.08
Ago
161.46
Winiarski
216.3
255
309.08
Simma
178.13
256
300.53
Xue
192.39
256
304.10
Higgins
226.04
255
311.51
Xue
192.39
256
304.10
Tomka
258.33
285
349.58
Yusuf
193.48
225
273.37
Castro
189.58
220
267.40
Yusuf
193.48
218
266.37
Ruda
172.92
189
232.23
-6-
ex parte
ex parte
In each of the eight groups, the Top Two Teams advance to the Round of 16. Within each group, teams are ranked according to 1) wins, then 2) Neustadtl Sonneborn-Berger (SB) score, then 3) preliminary round z-points. 5
Bravo
4
6
853.20
793.20
5
Jennings
3
4
856.20
4
781.20
5
Mo
2
2
745.20
2
4
831.20
5
Waldock
1
2
706.20
Castro
2
3
777.20
5
Visscher
1
1
755.20
1
Yusuf
2
2
741.20
5
Carneiro
1
1
665.20
2
Tomka
3
6
885.20
6
Pinto
4
8
860.20
2
Higgins
3
5
829.20
6
Skotnikov
3
4
804.20
2
Alfaro
3
4
859.20
6
Baxter
2
1
808.20
2
Xue
2
1
796.20
6
Aguilar
2
1
769.20
2
Klaestad
1
0
726.20
6
Jessup
1
0
788.20
3
Lipton
4
5
836.20
7
Gros
4
4
824.20
3
Winiarski
3
3
874.20
7
Hackworth
4
4
777.20
3
Hsu
2
4
813.20
7
McNair
2
1
793.20
3
Simma
2
2
776.20
7
Fabela
1
1
759.20
3
Tanaka
1
0
762.20
7
Armand
1
0
813.20
4
Trindade
4
7
846.20
8
Guerrero
4
6
866.20
4
Keith
3
4
825.20
8
Ugon
3
4
819.20
4
Camara
2
2
799.20
8
Amor
3
2
769.20
4
Rivero
1
1
759.20
8
Pathak
2
2
769.20
4
Shi
1
1
699.20
8
Crawford
2
0
790.20
4
Elias
1
1
684.20
Group
Team
Wins SB z-points
1
Gaja
3
5
1
Khan
3
1
Rau
1
Teams that won no matches are not shown. Round of 16 Pairings
Gaja v. Keith
Tomka v. Winiarski
Higgins v. Lipton
Khan v. Trindade
Bravo v. Ugon
Hackworth v. Pinto
Gros v. Skotnikov
Guerrero v. Jennings
Quarter Finals Winiarski v. Gaja
Trindade v. Lipton
Jennings v. Gros 5th Place Matches
Semi Finals Gaja v. Trindade
Ugon v. Pinto
Jennings v. Ugon
Gros v. Pinto
Final Match
3rd Place Match
Trindade v. Jennings
Ugon v. Gaja
Lipton v. Winiarski
The Regional Oral Winning Teams, Universiti Teknologi MARA (Asia Pacific), Gujarat National Law University (South Asia), and Kenya School of Law (Africa), each received a copy of the Kluwer publication “Arbitral Awards as Investments: Treaty Interpretation and the Dynamics of International Investment Law”. -7-
Written Results – Memorials Alias 1. Hsu 2. Baxter 3. Fabela 4. Gros 5. Gaja 6. Tomka 7. Rivero 8. Carneiro 9. Khan 10. Keith 11. Bravo 12. Trindade 13. Tanaka 14. Rau 15. Aguilar 16. Amor 17. Guerrero Alias 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
Skotnikov Gaja Tomka Jennings Amor Bravo Trindade Guerrero Winiarski 10. Alfaro 11. Waldock 12. Keith Higgins 14. Armand Pathak 16. Fabela 17. Hsu
Claimant 280.43 264.22 263.04 261.96 258.7 256.52 253.26 252.17 247.83 243.48 240.22 238.04 235.87 234.78 232.61 228.26 227.26 Respondent 288.54 263.54 258.33 257.29 256.52 252.08 250 241.67 241.67 234.38 227.08 226.04 226.04 222.92 222.92 221.88 219.79
18. Ugon 19. Lachs 20. Alfaro 21. Visscher 22. Winiarski Elias 24. Pinto Ruda 26. Higgins 27. Jennings 28. Simma Singh 30. Hackworth 31. Lipton 32. Skotnikov 33. Armand 34. Lacharriere Yusuf
225 219.57 218.48 217.39 216.3 216.3 215.22 215.22 214.13 210.87 208.7 208.7 207.61 207.52 196.74 194.57 193.48 193.48
18. Rau 19. Ugon 20. Baxter Xue 22. Gros Pinto 24. Singh 25. Lacharriere 26. Hackworth 27. Lipton 28. Klaestad 29. Khan Tanaka 31. Jessup 32. Castro 33. Camara 34. Elias Robinson
217.71 216.67 212.5 212.5 211.46 211.46 210.42 204.17 202.86 202.08 201.04 195.83 195.83 195.57 189.58 187.5 183.33 183.33
-8-
36. Pathak Xue 38. Ago 39. McNair 40. Klaestad Camara Crawford Mo Tarassov 45. Castro 46. Waldock 47. Ladreit 48. Shi 49. Koroma 50. Robinson Koretsky 52. Jessup
36. Rivero 37. Simma 38. McNair Crawford 40. Ruda 41. Koroma 42. Mo 43. Aguilar 44. Visscher Ago 46. Carneiro 47. Ladreit 48. Koretsky 49. Lachs 50. Yusuf Tarassov Shi
192.39 192.39 189.13 185.96 185.87 185.87 185.87 185.87 185.87 183.7 182.61 179.35 167.39 165.22 156.52 156.52 153.35
179.17 178.13 175 175 172.92 168.75 166.67 163.54 161.46 161.46 160.42 159.38 154.17 153.13 150 150 150