VIA FEDEX OVERNIGHT March 21,2014 Ingrid Ferrell, Executive ...

Mar 21, 2014 - Monongahela Power & Potomac Edison. Alternative & Renewable Energy Portfolio Standard Compliance Plan and Annual Report. Page 1 ...
4MB Sizes 2 Downloads 176 Views
5007 NASA Boulevard Fairmoni, WV 26554

-

A FirstEnergy Company

Gary A. Jack Senior Corporate Counsel

Telephone: 304.534.7409 Fax: 330.315.9939

March 21,2014

VIA FEDEX OVERNIGHT Ingrid Ferrell, Executive Secretary Public Service Commission of West Virginia 201 Brooks Street Charleston, WV 25301 Re:

Monongahela Power Company and The Potomac Edison Company Alternative and Renewable Energy Resource Credits Compliance Plan and Annual Report: Case No. 14-1Wb-E-P

Dear Ms. Ferrell: Enclosed for filing are an original and twelve copies of the Alternative and Renewable Energy Resource Credits Compliance Plan and Annual Report on behalf of Monongahela Power Company and The Potomac Edison Company. We ask for the Commission's review and acceptance of the annual Report. Sincerely,

Gary A. Jack " Senior Corporate Counsel WV State Bar No. 1855

GAJ/jss Enclosures cc:

Jacqueline Roberts, CAD

Monongahela Power Company & The Potomac Edison Company Alanative and Renewable Energy Portfolio Standard Compliance Plan and Annual Report In accordance with Rule 8 of the Rules Governing Alternative and Renewable Energy Portfolio Standard (“Portfolio Rules”), Monongahela Power Company (“Mon Power”) and The Potomac Edison Company (“Potomac Edison” or collectively the “Companies”) respectfully submit the following Alternative and Renewable Energy Portfolio Standard Compliance Plan Annual Report for calendar year 2013 for consideration by the West Virginia Public Service Commission (the “Commission”). As per Portfolio Rule 8.4, on or before March 31 of each year following the Commission’s approval of an electric utility’s compliance plan under Portfolio Rule 8.1, the electric utility shall submit to the Commission an annual progress report demonstrating compliance with the Portfolio Rules. The information required by Portfolio Rule 8.4 is provided below. 8.4.a. The electric utility’s sales to retail customers in West Virginia as recorded at the customer’s meter in the previous two calendar years, by year, in total number of megawatt hours. Please refer to Exhibit 1 for Mon Power and Potomac Edison’s individual retail metered sales and combined retail metered sales for the period calendar years 2012 and 2013 on a per MWh basis. The data is segregated by utility and service type (residential, commercial, industrial and street lighting). 8.4.b. The total amount of energy the electric utility has generated, purchased or procured from alternative or renewable energy resources as of December 31 of the previous calendar year. Please refer to Exhibit 2 for the total amount of energy the Companies have generated, purchased or procured from qualifylng alternative or renewable resources as of December 31, 2013. 8.4.b.L The portions, stated separately, of the total amount of energy required in Rule 8.4.b corresponding to energy generated, purchased or procured from the combustion of natural gas and generated from supercritical technology, if any; Please refer to Exhibit 2 for the total amount of energy the Companies have generated, purchased or procured from qualifylng alternative or renewable resources as of December 31, 2013. Please note that none of the generation is from the combustion of natural gas. Supercritical generation is represented by Fort Martin, Harrison and Monongahela Power & Potomac Edison Alternative & Renewable Energy Portfolio Standard Compliance Plan and Annual Report Page 1

,

I :Pleasants power stations. Additional comments on the certification of the individual resources under the Alternative and Renewable Energy Portfolio Standard are also documented in Exhibit 2 including supercritical technology.

8.4.b.2. The electric utility's sales to retail customers in West Virginia as recorded at the customer's meter in the two previous calendar years, by year, corresponding to voluntary purchases by retail customers of energyfrom renewable sources, if any; None.

8.4.c. The balance of the credits from alternative and renewable energy resource facilities the electric utility has purchased or procured as of December 31 of the previous calendar year. Please refer to Exhibit 2 for the total amount of energy the Companies have generated, purchased or procured from qualifylng alternative or renewable resources as of December 31, 20 13. Additional comments on the certification of the individual resources under the Alternative and Renewable Energy Portfolio Standard are also documented in Exhibit 2.

8.4.d. The balance of the credits the utility has been awarded or purchased from energy efficiency or demand-side energy initiative projects or greenhouse gas emission reduction or offsetprojects as of December 31 of the previous calendar year. None.

8.4.d.l. The electric utility's sales to retail customers in West Virginia as recorded at the customer's meter in the two previous years, by year, corresponding to voluntary purchases by retail customers of offsets or greenhouse gas emission reductions offsetting retailpower use, if any. None.

8.4.e. A comparison of the budgeted and actual costs as compared to the estimated cost of the por$olio standard compliance plan, including the information on credit transactions required under Rule d.La, subject to the same public disclosureprovisions in Rule 6.Lb. Please refer to Exhibit 3 for a comparison of actual and budgeted costs as compared to the estimated cost of the portfolio standard compliance plan. The net compliance position shows that the Companies anticipate generating enough credits using currently available resources for the 15-year term and that no additional development, purchase or procurement of credits will be necessary. Therefore, there is no anticipated additional incremental cost expectation beyond the costs to achieve any energy efficiency/demand reduction initiatives as were discussed in 8.2.f of the compliance filing.

Monongahela Power & Potomac Edison Alternative & Renewable Energy Portfolio Standard Compliance Plan and AMual Report Page 2

8.4.J A n accounting issued by PJM-EIS that shows the number of alternative and renewable energy resource creditspurchased and/or held by the electric utility as of December 31 of the previous calendar year. Please refer to Exhibit 4.

8.4.g. An accounting issued by PJM-EIS that shows the portions, reported separately, of alternative and renewable energy resource credits retired to meet the Portfolio Standard of the previous calendar year corresponding to energy generated from the combustion of natural gas and energy generated from supercritical technology, if any. Not applicable. Compliance through the retirement of credits under the alternative and renewable portfolio standard law does not become effective until 2015 .

8.4.h. The vintage year and serial number of the greenhouse gas emission reductions or offsets awarded or purchased and attestation by the electric utility that all greenhouse gas emission reductions or offsets used for compliance under this rule were retired in the offset registry of sthe approved greenhouse gas program in which the reductions or offsets were registeredfor the purpose of this rule. Not applicable. ~ Q ~ redactbizs or oflssets under Rule 5.4 in any 8.4.Z. Fm m y credits ~ w Q K ~ Hemission previous year, an attestation that the offsets remain in compliance with the reversal rules of the greenhouse gas program where the reductions or offsets were registered.

Not applicable.

8.4.j. A list of any requirements and a description of how the electric-utility satisJied or will satisfjt those requirements if an electric utility is subject to an alternative energy, advanced energy, renewable energy or similar energy portfolio standard in any other state. Mon Power is not subject to any alternative energy, advanced energy, renewable energy or similar energy portfolio standard in any other state. Potomac Edison is subject to a renewable portfolio standard in the state of Maryland.

Monongahela Power & Potomac Edison Alternative & Renewable Energy Portfolio Standard Compliance Plan and Annual Report Page 3

/ -

Maryland Maryland's Renewable Energy Portfolio Standard, enacted in May 2004 and revised in 2008, 2010, 2012 and 2013 requires electricity suppliers (all utilities and competitive retail suppliers) to use renewable energy sources to provide for a minimum portion of their retail sales. Beginning in 2006, electricity suppliers were to provide 1% of retail electricity sales in the state from Tier 1 renewables and 2.5% from Tier 2 renewables. The renewable requirement increases gradually, ultimately reaching a level of 20% from Tier 1 resources in 2022 and beyond, and 2.5% from Tier 2 resources from 2006 through 2018. The Tier 2 requirement sunsets, dropping to 0% in 20 19 and beyond. Tier 1 resources as of the writing of this compliance progress update include solar energy including energy from photovoltaic technologies and solar water heating systems; wind; qualifylng biomass; methane from the anaerobic decomposition of organic materials in a landfill or wastewater treatment plant; geothermal; ocean (including energy from waves, tides, currents and thermal differences); fuel cells powered by methine or biomass; small hydroelectric plants (systems less than 30 MW in capacity and in operation as of 1/1/2004); poultry litter-to-energy; refuse-derived fuel and certain geothermal heating and cooling systems and biomass systems that generate thermal energy. Tier 2 sources include hydroelectric power other than pump-storage generation.

Electricity suppliers demonstrate compliance with the standard by accumulating RECs equivalent to the required percentages outlined above. A REC has a three-year life during which it may be transferred, sold, or otherwise redeemed (ie. qualifying RECs for compliance in 2013 include RECs produced in 201 1,2012 and 2013). Monongahela Power & Potomac Edison Alternative & Renewable Energy Portfolio Standard Compliance Plan and Annual Report Page 4

, U

Each electricity supplier must submit a report to the Maryland PSC annually that demonstrates compliance with the RPS. An electricity supplier that fails to meet the standard must pay into the Maryland Strategic Energy Investment Fund at a rate of $40 / REC for non-solar Tier 1 shortfalls; $15 / REC for Tier 2 shortfalls; Solar o 2009-2014 $400/SREC o 2015&2016 $35O/SREC $200/SREC o 20178~2018 o 2019&2020 $1SO/SREC $1OO/SREC 0 2021 & 2022 o 2023 &beyond $SO/SREC Electricity suppliers may recover costs incurred to comply with the standard in the form of a generation surcharge on all customers. However, the RPS law provides compliance cost caps and provisions for delaying compliance with the solar set-aside. If the actual or projected dollar-for-dollar cost for purchasing solar RECs in any one year is greater than or equal to 1% of the electric supplier’s total annual electricity sales revenues in Maryland, the electricity supplier may request that the PSC delay by one year each of the scheduled percentages for solar and allow the solar percentage required for that year to continue to apply to the electricity supplier c LGT the followhig yea, The delcy will continue each yezir wtil the ~ c t u d or anticipted cost is less than 1% of the supplier’s annual sales revenue in Maryland, at which time the supplier will be subject to the next scheduled percentage increase. All Potomac Edison Maryland utility renewable obligations are currently procured through the Standard Offer Service (SOS) procurement process with the exception of hourlypriced service load which SOS obligation is purchased fiom the PJM spot market. The spot W C requirement is filled annually after the fact by Potomac Edison. 8.4.k Any other information required by the Commission to prevent the double counting of credits. The Commission at this time has not requested any such information. 8.4.1. Such further information as required by the Commission. Per the Commission’s March 8, 2012, Order in Case No. 11-1184-E-P approving alternative energy resource certification for Fort Martin power station as a wholly owned asset of Mon Power and Harrison and Pleasants power stations as jointly owned resources of Mon Power and Allegheny Energy Supply Company, “In all future reports and compliance filing(s) Mo(n) Power is required to report and reconcile the total credits recorded within GATS for each unit and the portion of the GATS account that represents Mon Power’s credits.”’ Such requirement

’ Commission Order in Case No. 11-1184-E-P at page 6. Monongahela Power & Potomac Edison Alternative & Renewable Energy Portfolio Standard Compliance Plan and Annual Report Page 5

also applies to the Commission’s alternative energy resource certification of Bath County Power Station as a jointly owned resource of Mon Power and Allegheny Energy Supply Company in Case No. 11-0072-E-P. As such, please refer to Exhibit 5 for the breakdown of REC production for Mon Power and Allegheny Energy Supply’s ownership shares for Bath County, and Exhibit 6 for the breakdown of REC production for Mon Power and Allegheny Energy Supply’s ownership shares for Harrison and Pleasants power stations. Additionally, per the Commission’s July 17, 2013, Order in Case No. 13-0435-E-P approving the Companies alternative and renewable energy portfolio standard compliance plan annual progress report, the Commission requested that the Companies file an update to their original compliance plan providing actual and updated budget data as to more clearly monitor the Companies’ ability to meet its compliance obligations over the term of the plan. The Companies have responded to this request by providing a new Exhibit 3 which provides yearly actual and forecasted: (1) customer metered load MWh; (2) compliance obligations; (3) REC production by unit; and (4) a running review of the Companies compliance position.

Monongahela Power & Potomac Edison Alternative & Renewable Energy Portfolio Standard Compliance Plan and Annual Report Page 6

EXHIBIT 1

Exhibit 1: Monongahela Power Company & The Potomac Edison Company Historic Usage 2012 & 2013 MWh (metered sales)

WV Renewable Compliance Plan Annual Progress Report 2013 - Mon Power Potomac Edison

EXHIBIT 2

Exhibit 2: Mon Power WV RPS Compliant Generation (MWh)

'

ALBRIGHT #3 BATH COUNTY' FORT MARTIN GRANT TOWN HANNIBAL HARRISON PLEASANTS WILLOW ISLAND E

wvu

I

0 1,492,568

I

0 605,570

7,930,432

7,930,431

636,634

636,634

253,228 12,700,814

506,456 4,634,617

8,109,546

451,368

0 404,476

0 0

Notes: 1 - Intermittent renewable resource that burns sawdust as fuel stock as economically available. A Petition for Certification for Albright #3 was filed with the Commission on January 27, 2011. On July 19, 201 1 the Commission granted the petition for certification of Aibright #3 for Mon Power. REC creation for Albright #3 started in July2011. On September 1, 2012, Albright Power Station was deactivated in accordance with the Companies' filing in Case No. 12-0308-E-PC. NO further RECs will be produced from Albright #3. 2 - A Petition for Certificationfor Mon Power's ownership share of Bath County was filed with the Commission on January 27, 201 1. On July 19, 201 1 the Commission granted the petition for certification of Bath County for Mon Power's ownership share. REC creation for Bath County started in July 201 I. Credits reflect Mon Power's assigned output and ownership share. 3 - A Petition for Certification by Mon Power for Fort Martin, Harrison and Pleasants power stations was filed with the Commission on August 12, 201 1. On March

8,2012 the Commission granted the petition for certification of the Fort Martin, Harrison and Pleasants power stations for Mon Power. REC creation started in March 2012. On October 7,2013, the Commission granted the petition by Mon Power to acquire the 79.46 percent ownership interest held by AE Supply in the Harrison station, resulting in Mon Power being the sole owner of Harrison. Also, in the same petition, AE Supply acquired the 7.69 percent ownership interest held by Mon Power in the Pleasants station, resulting in AE Supply being the sole owner of Pleasants. Credits reflect Mon Power's assigned output and ownership share in Harrison and Pleasants power stations. 4 - A Petition for Certification for Grant Town was filed by AMBIT on January 6,201 1. On June 7, 2011 the Commission granted the petition. REC creation for Grant Town started in June 2011. 5 - The Commission approved the City of New Martinsviile's request for certification of the Hannibal unit on July 20, 201 1. REC creation for Hannibal is from JUIY 201 1 folward. Ownership of the RECs has been decided by Commission Order in Case No. 11-0249-E-P and has been affirmed by the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals through its July 12, 2012 order. The City subsequently filed with the United States District Court at the Southern District of WV to overturn the Commission's Order arguing that the Order is in violation of PURPA law. On September 30, 2013, the United States District Court af the Sourthern District o f w v affirmed the previous decision by the Commission and dismissed the complaints filed by the City. On December 3, 2013, Mon Power requested that PJM-EIS formally recognize these RECs as wholly owned by Mon Power during the term of the PURPA power purchase agreement. As a renewable energy resource Hannibal is entitled to two credits for every REC produced for WV compliance purposes.

6 - Intermittent renewable resource that burns tire derived fuel as fuel stock is economically available. A Petition for Certificationfor Willow Island #2 was filed with the Commission on January 27, 201 1. On July 19, 201 1 the Commission granted the petition for certification of Willow Island #2 for Mon Power. REC creation eiigibilityfor Willow Island #2 started in July 201 1. On September 1, 2012, Willow Island Power Station was deactivated in accordance with the Companies' filing in Case No. 12-0308-E-PC. No further RECs will be produced from Willow Island #2.

7 - Due to the litigation as to the ownership of RECs from WVU, Morgantown Energy Associates declined to file for certification of the facility to produce RECs in WV. While located in WV, the facility continued to only produce PA qualifying RECs. In accordance with the Commission's Order in Case No. 11-0249-E-P the Companies filed for certificationof the faciiityas an alternative and renewable energy resource for the production of RECs. On February 14, 2013, the wv Commission Staff filed a memorandum supporting the Companies' filing. Subsequently on June 10, 2013, the Compananies filed supplemental data at the request of Staff for the conversion of waste steam to a MWh equivalent so that credits can be produced as renewable energy from WVU's waste steam which will be entitled to two credits for every REC produced from the waste steam for WV compliance purposes. Commission Staff filed an additional memorandum supporting the Companies' supplemental filing on July 2, 2013, for the methodologyfor converting waste steam flow to megawatts to be used to create RECs from the facility. On March 10, 2014, the Commission granted the petition for certification of WVU's facility as a qualified energy resource and renewable energy

WV Renewable Compliance Plan Annual Progress Report 2013 - Mon Power Potomac Edison

-

EXHIBIT 3

-

Exhibit 3 Compliance Forecast 2011 2025

Retall Sales to apply against %

Willow Island #2

Tire Derived

Grant Town PURPA

Waste Coal

-

I Net REC Position (6) + (C) (A) dive or Banked RECs from prevlous year

I

It is expected that Mon Power's existing assets will generate sufficient RECs to meet the WV renewable obligation through 2025.

' The WV PSC has approved WVU to Produce RECs at two times the MWh Production ofthe unit.

RECs are antlclpated to begln accruing with the March 2014 production month WV Renewable Compliance Plan Annual Progress Report 2013 - Mon Power Potomac Edimn

1

EXHIBIT 4

*

MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET8fiO44201

Exhibit 4 Mon Power WV renewable energy resource credits

-1

Bath County Bath County. Bath County Bath County. Bath County Bath CountyBath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County. Bath County Bath CountyBath CountyBath County Bath County Bath County Bath CountyBath CountyBath CountyBath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath Cauntv -

-

Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped S,torage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumoed Storaae

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA

VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA

VA VA VA VA

-

2011108 2011109 2011110 2011111 2011112 2012101 2012102 2012/03 2012/04 2012105 2012106 2012107 2012/08 2012/09 2012110 2012/11 2012/12 2013101 2013102 2013103 2013104 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109 2013110 2013111

267960 1t o 82800 284870 Ito 53724 299206 1 to 60097 313758 1 to 58653 327917 1 to 54153 341772.1 to 26381 356361 1 to 28409 372711 1 to 50035 389742 1to 46355 412314 1t o 69668 439720 1to 72345 460531 1t o 81305 483623 1t o 82210 513436 1 to 64845 529984 1 t o 46128 549687 1 t o 52096 569383 1 to 47015 583980 Ito 53213 601698.1 t o 44376 621189 1 to 42287 646629.1 to 44445 675418 1to 48823 705229.1 t o 65320 735396.1 t o 78940 765345 1t o 66481 794406 1t o 41619 823969 1t o 42632 850483 1t o 36302

2012103

374634 1to 266318 389714 1 to 284293 412202.1 to 358463 444238 1to 334552 460499 1t o 322448 483591 1to 360479 513622 1to 349205 529953 1 to 365878 549658. Ito 336231 569363 1 to 312876 583951 1 to 243718 601672 It o 336812 621164- 1 to317617 646600 1to 339797 675385 1to 370691 727672 1 to 299069 736641 1to 349550 774459 1to 316109 794373.1 t o 341859

-

Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternptive Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative

Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource

Alternative Alternative Aiternatlve Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternative Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative

Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy

WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV.005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-OO5.AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-OOCAE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS

82,800 53,724 60,097 58,653 54,153 26,381 28,409 50,035 46,355 69,668 72,345 81,385 82,210 64,845 46,128 52,096 47,015 53,213 44,376 42,287 44,445 48,823 65,320 78,940 66,481 41,619 42,632 36,302

12-WV.0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV.0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV.0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-PIE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0027-AE-ACTSC

284,293 358,463 334,552 322,448 360,479 349,205 365,878 336,231 312,876 243,718 336,812 317,617 339,797 370,691 299,069 349,550 316,109 341,859

I

-

MSET90050101

Fort Martin Power Station 1

Coal Bituminous and Anthracite

MSET90050101 MSET90050101 MSET90050101 MSET90050101 MSET90050101 MSET90050101 MSET90050101 MSET90050101 MSET90050101 MSET90050101

Fort Martin Power Station Fort Martin Power Station Fort Martin Power Station Fort Martin Power Station * Fort Martin Power Station Fort Martin Power Station Fort Martin Power Station Fort Martin Power Station Fort Martin Power Station Fort Martin Power Station Fort Martin Power Station Fort Martin Power Station Fort Martin Power Station Fort Martin Power Station Fort Martin Power Station

-

Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite

.

Coal Bituminous and Anthracite

MSET90050101 MSET90050101 MSET90050101 MSET90050101 MSET90050101 MSET90050101 MSET90050101

~

~

-

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

MSET90050101

Fort Martin Power Station - 1 Fort Martin Power Station - 1 Fort Martin Power Station I

MSET90050101

Fort Martin Power Station 1

~

-

WV WV WV WV WV

WV WV WV WV WV WV WV WV

WV WV

WV WV WV WV

-

2012/04 2012105 2012106 2012107 2012108 2012109 2012/10 2012111 2012112 2013101 2013102 2013/03 2013104 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109

Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource

-

*

-

WV Renewable Compliance Plan Annual Progress Report 2013 Mon Power Potomac Edison

1

EXHIBIT 4

Exhibit 4 Mon P o w e r WV r e n e w a b l e e n e r g y resource credits

-

MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102 MSET90050102

Fort Martin Power Station 2 Fort Martin Power Station 2 Fort Martin Power Station 2 Fort Martin Power Station - 2 Fort Martin Power Station - 2 Fort Martin Power Station 2 Fort Martin Power Station - 2 Fort Martin Power Station 2 Fort Martin Power Station 2 Fort Martin Power Station 2 Fort Martin Power Station 2 Fort Martin Power Station 2 Fort Martin Power Statlon 2 Fori Martin Power Station - 2 Fort Martin Power Station. 2 Fort Martin Power Station - 2 Fort Martin Power Station 2

MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101 MSET90760101

Grant Town Power Plant GENl Grant Town Power Plant - GENl Grant Town Power Plant - GENI Grant Town Power Plant GENl Grant Town Power Plant GENl Grant Town Power Plant GENl Grant Town Power Plant - GENl Grant Town Power Plant GENI Grant Town Power Plant GENl Grant Town Power Plant - GENl Grant Town Power Plant - GENI Grant Town Power Plant GENl Grant Town Power Plant GENl Grant Town Power Plant GENl Grant Town Power Plant - GENl Grant Town Power Plant - GENl Grant Town Power Plant GENI Grant Town Power Plant GENl Grant Town Power Plant GENI Grant Town Power Plant - GENl Grant Town Power Plant - GENl Grant Town Power Plant GENl Grant Town Power Plant GENl Grant Town Power Plant GENl Grant Town Power Plant GENl Grant Town Power Plant GENI Grant Town Power Plant GENI Grant Town Power Plant GENI Grant Town Power Plant GENl

~

-

-

~

~

-

-

-

Coal Bitumlnousmd Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal -Bituminous and Anthracite Coal .Bituminous and Anthracite Coal -Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite

-

~

-

Coal Waste/Other Coal Waste/Other Coal Wastelother Coal Waste/Other Coal. Waste/Other Coal Waste/Other Coal - Waste/Other Coal Wastelother Coal - Waste/Other Coal - Waste/Other Coal - Waste/Other Coal Waste/Other Coal Waste/Other Coal Wastelother Coal Waste/Other Coal. Wastelother Coal Wastelother Coal Wastelother Coal Wastelother Coal. Wastelother Coal Waste/Other Coal. Wastelother Coal Wastelother Coal Wastelother Coal - Waste/Other Coal Wastelother Coal Wastelother Coal - Wastelother Coal Wastelother ~

-

. .

~

.

WV WV WV

wv wv wv wv WV

wv wv

wv WV

wv WV WV

wv

wv

wv wv wv WV WV

wv wv wv wv WV

wv wv wv WV

wv wv WV

wv WV WV WV WV WV WV WV WV

wv

wv wv

2012106 2012108 2012109 2012HO 2012111 2012112 20 13/01 2013102 2013103 2013104 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109 2013110 2013111

455378. It o 112011 483592 1 t o 268089 525502 1 t o 338582 529954 1 t o 336412 549659 1 t o 335661 569364 1 t o 359566 583952 1 t o 369773 601673 1 t o 327153 621165 1 t o 365687 646601 1 t o 251536 675386.1 t o 333416 724746 1 t o 356100 736734.1 t o 300927 775110 Ito 345493 794374 Ito 339845 823942.1 t o 367649 866761 1t o 276530

201 1107 201 1108

254574 1t o 56536 272451 1 t o 56808 286612 1t o 31289 301272 1 t o 60863 315175 1 t o 55937 329467 1 t o 50496 342054 1 t o 60667 357886 1 t o 56219 374633 1t o 59941 389732 1t o 56356 412303.1 t o 53648 436471 1t o 54528 460519 1 to 53876 483612 1t o 56615 511659 1 to 35814 529974.1 t o 57351 549677 It o 55349 569375. It o 59917 583970 1 t o 55568 601688 1 to 51794 621181 1 t o 56725 646619 1 t o 48243 675406 1 t o 59095 705339 1 t o 49845 736796 1 t o 57812 765344 1 t o 52757 794394 1 t o 35855 823958 1 to 59921 850482 1 t o 52436

2011109 2011110 2011111 2011112

2012101 2012/02 2012/03 2012/04 2012105

2012106 2012107 2012l08 2012lO9

2012/10 2012/11 2012/12 2013/01 2013/02 2013/03 2013/04 2013/05 2013/06 2013/07 2013/08 2013/09 2013/10 2013/11

-

-

-

WV Renewable Compliance Plan Annual Progress Repolt 2013 - Mon Power Potomac Edlson

Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternative

Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource

12-WV-0028-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0028-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0028-AE-ACTSC I2.WV-0028-AE-ACTSC I2-WV-0028-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0028-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0028-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0028-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0028-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0028-AE-ACTSC 12.WV.0028-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0028-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0028-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0028-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0028-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0028-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-OO28-AE-ACTSC

112,011 268,089 338,582 336,412 335,661 359,566 369,773 327,153 365.687 251,536 333,416 356,100 300,927 345,493 339.845 367,649 276,530

Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternatlve Alternative

Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource

WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV.0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV.0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002.AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV.0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC WV.0002-AE-WC WV-0002-AE-WC

56,536 56,808 31,289 60,863 55,937 50,496 60,667 56,219 59,941 56,356 53,648 54,528 53,876 56,615 35,814 57,351 55,349 59,917 55,568 51,794 56,725 48,243 59,095 49,845 57,812 52,757 35,855 59,921 52,436

2

EXHIBIT 4

P

Exhibit 4: Mon Power WV renewable energy resource credits

MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101 MSET90774101

Covanta New Martinsville EnergyCovanta New Martinsville Energy Covanta New Martinsville Energy Covanta New Martinsville Energy. Covanta New Martinsvllle Energy. Covanta New Martinsville Energy Covanta New Martinsville Energy Covanta New Martinsville Energy Covanta New Martinsville EnergyCovanta New Martinsville Energy Covanta New Martinsville EnergyCovanta New Martinsville EnergyCovanta New Martinsviiie EnergyCovanta New Martlnsviiie EnergyCovanta New Martinsville EnergyCovanta New Martinsville EnergyCovanta New Martinsville Energy Covanta New Martinsville Energy Covanta New Martinsville Energy Covanta New Martinsvllle Energy Covanta New Martinsville Energy Covanta New Martinsville Energy Covanta New Martinsville Energy Covanta New Martinsville Energy Covanta New Martinsville Energy Covanta New Martlnsville Energy Covanta New Martinsville Energy

MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101

Harrison Power Station Harrison Power Station Harrison Power Station Harrison Power Station Harrison Power Station Harrison Power Station. Harrison Power Station Harrison Power Station Harrison Power Station Harrison Power Station Harrison Power Station. Harrison Power Station Harrison Power Station. Harrison Power Station. Harrison Power Station Harrison Power Station Harrison Power Station. Harrison Power Station -

-

-

Hydro Conventional Hydro. Conventional Hydro Conventional Hydro Conventional Hydro - Conventional Hydro. Conventional Hydro Conventlonal Hydro. Conventional Hydro Conventional Hydro - Conventional Hydro Conventional Hydro Conventional Hydro - Conventional Hydro. Conventional Hydro Conventional Hydro Conventional Hydro - Conventional Hydro. Conventional Hydro. Conventional Hydro Conventional Hydro Conventlonal Hydro Conventional Hydro Conventional Hydro Conventlonal Hydro - Conventional Hydro Conventional Hydro Conventional

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

-1

-

-1 -1 1 -1 -1 1 -1 -1 -1 -1 1 -1 -

1 1 1 1 1 1

-

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

-

. .

-

Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite

-

wv wv wv WV WV

WV

wv WV WV WV WV WV

wv wv wv WV

wv WV

wv wv WV

wv wv wv wv wv wv

wv wv wv wv WV WV

wv wv wv wv WV

WV WV

wv WV WV WV

wv

. -

2011/09 2011/10 2011/11 2011/12 2012/01 2012/02 2012/03 2012/04 2012105 2012/06 2012/07 20 12/08 20 12/09 2012/10 2012/11 2012112 2013/01 2013/02 2013/03 2013/04 2013/05 2013106 2013/07 2013/08 2013/09 2013/10 2013/11

283640 Ito 14172 298258 1 to 19533 312404 1 to 20145 326418 1 to 18127 339311 1 to 17567 354834 1t o 22108 370891 .It o 21373 389733 1t o 20460 412304 1t o 21867 436453 1 t o 12544 460520 1 t o 12698 483613 1 t o 10918 510557 1t o 9899 529975-1 to11190 549678 1t o 17459 569376 1t o 16829 583971 1t o 22584 601689 1t o 19096 621182- 1 to25229 646620 1 t o 23770 675407 1 t o 23204 707043 1 t o 22652 736731 1 t o 23851 764027 1 t o 19867 794395 1 t o 13571 823959 1 t o 15773 850730 1 t6 24891

2012106 2012107 2012108 2012109 2012110 2012111 2012112 20 13101 2013102 20 13/03 2013104 20 13/05 20 13/06 2013107 20 13/08 2013109 2013110 2013111

446385.1 to 73313 460500 1 t o 85456 483593 Ito 79513 517231 1t o 38007 529955 1t o 45439 549660-It094619 569365 1t o 81915 583953 1t o 94333 601674 1t o 72454 621166 1t o 100063 646602 1 t o 60436 675387.1 t o 78548 706937 1 t o 92630 736491 1 t o 85071 764025 1 t o 93731 794375 1 t o 79510 823943 1 t o 466029 858235.1 t o 331324

-

WV Renewable Compllance Pian Annual Progress Report 2013 - Mon Power Potomac Edison

Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource Renewable Energy Resource

Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative

Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy Energy

Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource Resource

WV.0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV.0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006.REN-HRR WV.0006-REN.HRR WV.0006-REN.HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR WV-0006-REN-HRR

12-WV.0029-AE-ACTSC

73,313 85,456 79,513 38,007 45,439 94,619 81,915 94,333 72,454 100,063 60,436 78,548 92,630 85,071 93,731 79,510 466,029 331,324

12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE.ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE.ACTSC 12.WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV.0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE.ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC

3

EXHIBIT 4

Exhiblt 4: Mon Power WV renewable energy resource credits

-

MSET90060102

Harrison Power Station 2

MSET90060102 MSET90060102

Harrison Power Station - 2 Harrison Power Station - 2

MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102

MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103

Harrison Power Station - 2 Harrison Power Station - 2 Harrison Power Station - 2 Hardson Power Station - 2 Harrison Power Station - 2 Harrison Power Station. 2 Harrison Power Station - 2 Harrison Power Station - 2 Hamson Power Station - 2 Harrison Power Station - 2

Harnson Power Station 2 Harnson Power Station 2

-

Harrison Power Station 3 Harnson Power Station. 3 Harnson Power Station 3 Harnson Power Station .3 Harnson Power Station .3 Harrison Power Station - 3 Harrison Power Station 3 Harnson Power Station. 3 Harrison Power Station 3 Harnson Power Station 3 Harrison Power Station 3 Harrison Power Station 3 Harrlson Power Station - 3 Harrison Power Station - 3 Harrison Power Station 3 Hamson Power Station 3 Harrison Power Station 3

-

-

Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite

-

Coal Bituminous and Anthracite

wv

2012104

389715 Ito 38272

Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte

wv

2012105 2012107 2012108 2012109 2012/10 2012111 2012112 2013101 201 3102 20 13/03 20 13/05 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109

412285.1 t o 47281 439721 1 t o 55432 460501 1 to83612 483594 Ito 67900 513437 1t o 36684 529956 1t o 38543 549661 1 t o 74985 569366 1 t o 53897 583954 1 t o 77545 601675 1 to 51763 621167 1t o 51246 675388 1t o 38649 705230 1 t o 72818 736033 1 t o 92736 765327 1 t o 89259 794376 1 t o 69487

2012104 2012105 2012106 2012107 2012108 2012109 2012110 2012111 2012112 2013101 2013102 2013103 2015104 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108

389716 It o 9713 412286 1 t o 75418 453874.1 to 68998 460502.1 t o 67048 483595.1 to 78957 524840. Ito 54447 529957 1t o 41646 549662 1t o 92850 569367 1to 82279 583955 1 t o 94634 601676 1 t o 89672 621168 1 t o 62240 646603 1 t o 85919 675389 1 to 81108 723434 1 to 82792 736352 1t o 58288 774517 1t o 78791

Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bitumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite oal -Bituminous and Anthracite

-

-

Coal Bltuminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite

-

wv wv WV

wv wv WV WV

wv

wv wv WV

wv WV

wv WV

WV

wv WV WV WV

wv WV

wv

wv

WV WV

wv wv wv wv WV

wv

2012106

Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Aiternatlve Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative

Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource

Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative

Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource

-

-

-

-

WV Renewable Compliance Plan Annual Progress Report 2013 Mon Power Potomac Edison

12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE.ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV4030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030.AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-OO3O.AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE.ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC

12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE.ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12.WV.0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV.0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031.AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV.0031-AE.ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC

4

EXHIBIT 4

Exhibit 4 Mon Power WV renewable energy resource credits

1 -1 -1 -1 1 -1

- Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite .Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite

wv wv wv wv

Bituminous and Anthraclte

wv

MSET90100101

Pleasants Power Station 1

Coal Bituminous and Anthracite

MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101

Pleasants Power Station Pleasants Power Station Pleasants Power Station Pleasants Power Station Pleasants Power Station Pleasants Power Station Pleasants Power Station. Pleasants Power Station Pleasants Power Station Pleasants Power Station Pieasants Power Station Pieasants Power Station Pleasants Power Station Pieasants Power Station Pieasants Power Station Pleasants Power Station

Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal. oal

MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101

MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSETSOI00102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

.

Pleasants Power Station. 2 Pleasants Power Station. 2 Pleasants Power Station. 2 Pleasants Power Station - 2 Pleasants Power Station - 2 Pleasants Power Station 2 Pleasants Power Station 2 Pleasants Power Station. 2 Pleasants Power Station - 2 Pleasants Power Station 2 Pleasants Power Statlon 2 Pleasants Power Station 2 Pleasants Power Station 2 Pleasants Power Station - 2 Pleasants Power Station 2 Pleasants Power Station 2

-

-

~

~

.Bituminous and Anthraclte

-

Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bitumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal - Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite

~

~

WV WV

wv WV WV

wv wv WV

wv WV WV WV

389718 1 t o 21374

2012105 2012106 2012107 2012108 2012109 20121lO

412288 1 t o 25058 437543 1 t o 31048 460504 1t o 24579 483597 1 t o 32399 509701 1 t o 30858 529959 1 t o 24778 549664 1 to 32884 569369 1t o 30011 583957 1t o 29472 601678.1 to21116 621170 1 t o 28890 646605 1 t o 30216 675391 1 t o 33501 705261 1 to 29718 736023 1 to 28481 773380 Ito 18167 794379.1 t o 26192

2012111 2012112 20 13101

wv

2013102 2013103 2013104 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109

wv wv wv wv wv wv wv

2012103 2012104 2012105 2012106 2012107 2012108 2012109

WV

20121lO

wv

2012111 2012H2 20 13101 2013102 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108

WV WV WV

wv wv wv WV

-

2012104

-

Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Aiternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternatlve

Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource

12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV.0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC I2-WV.0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032.AE.ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12.WV.0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC

-

Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Aiternatlve Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative

Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource

12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE.ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12.WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12.WV.0033.AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC

~

-

370756 1 t o 15171 389719 1 t o 26534 412289.1 t o 154i’O 437544 1 t o 26240 460505 Ito 19880 483598 1t o 31082 509809 1t o 32803 529960 1t o 26132 549665 1 t o 31828 569370 1t o 25132 583958 1 t o 33304 601679 1 t o 23439 675392 1 t o 22154 705262.1 t o 18600 735368 1 to 30507 773381 1 t o 28888

WV Renewable Compliance Plan Annual Progress Report 2013 - Mon Power Potomac Edlson

15,171 26,534 15,410 26,240 19,880 31,082 32,803 26,132 31,828 25,132 33,304 23,439 22,154 18,600 30,507 28,888

5

EXHIBIT 5

Exhibit 5: Mon Power WV renewable energy resource credits share of Bath County

trpate Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power

FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnerpy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnerav Solutlons Corn. FlrstEnerG Solutions Corp. .FlrstEnergy . .. -. Solutions Corp. ~., ,wwx * e ~ o n g . & $ p ; p ) f s

MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201 MSET96044201

-

Bath County 1 Bath County. 1 Bath County- 1 Bath County 1 Bath County 1 Bath county I Bath County 1 Bath County 1 Bath County 1 Bath County 1 Bath County 1 Bath County 1 Bath county I Bath County. I Bath county 1 Bath County. 1 Bath County 1 Bath County. 1 Bath County 1 Bath County 1 Bath County. 1 Bath County 1 Bath County 1 Bath County 1 Bath County 1 Bath County 1 Bath county 1

-

-1 -I -1 -1 1 -1 1 -1 -1 -1 -- 11 -1 -- 11 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 -I -1 -1 -I -1 1 -1

Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County. Bath County Bath County. Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath county Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County Bath County. Bath Countv

rotal Credns (ieneratad by Bath County on behaffofAIlsghenyM e y Supply 8 Monongahele P Total Credits Generated b y Bath County o n behalf of Allegheny Energy Supply Total Credits Generatedby Bath County on behalf of Monongahela Pdwer [email protected] Percentage of Credits Generated by Bath County on behalf of Allegheny Energy Supply Percentage of Credhs Qenerated by Bah Countv o n behalf ofMononnahsla Power Companv

Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage ' Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storaqe Pumped Storage

Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage Pumped Storage

VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA VA

2011108 2011109 20111lO 2011111 2011112 2012101 2012102 2012103 2012104 2012105 2012106 2012107 2012108 2012108 20121lO 2012111 2012112 2013101 2013102 2013103 2013104 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109 2013110 2013111

252573.1 to 86892 267960.1 to 82800 284870 1to 53724 299206 1to 60097 313758 1to 58653 327917 1to 54153 341772 1to 26381 356361 1to 28409 372711 1to 50035 389742 1to 46355 412314.1 to 69668 439720 1to 72345 460531 1 to 81385 483623 1 to 82210 513436 1 to 64845 529984 1 t o 46128 549687 1 t o 52096 569383 1 t o 47015 583980 1 to 53213 601698.1 to 44376 621189 1to 42287 646629 1to 44445 675418 1to 48823 705229 1to 65320 735396 1to 78940 765345 1to 66481 794406 1 to 41619 823969 1 to 42632 850483 1 t o 36302 874789 1 t o 41132

2011108 2011109 20111lO ZO11111 20111lZ 2012101 2012102 2012103 2012104 2012105 2012106 2012106 2012107 2012108 2012109 2012HO 2012111 2012112 2013101 2013102 2013103 201Y04 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109 2013110

252573 86893 to 213903 267960 82801 to 203840 284870 53725 to 132261 299206 60098 to 147949 313758 58654 to 144394 327917 54154 to 133317 341772 26382 to 64947 356361 28410 to 69939 372711 50036 to 123180 389742 46356 to 114120 412314- 69669 to 171512 439720 115305 to 178103 439720 72346 to 115304 460531 81386 to 200356 483623 82211t o 202389 513436 64846 to 159638 529984- 46129to 113560 549687 52097 to 128253 569383 47016 to I15745 583980. 53214to 131002 601698 44377 to 109249 621189-42288to 104105 646629 44446 to 109417 675418 48824 to 120196 705229 65321 to 160808 735396-78941t0194339 765345 66482 to 163667 794406 41620 to 102461 823969 42633 to 104955 850483 36303 t o 89371 874789.41133 to 101262

---

-

-

-

--

--

-

%i

o w Company

\ !

i

c i-

Alternative Enerav Resource Alternatlve Energ; Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource

WV-005-AE-HPS . _ . WV-OOCAE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-OOCAE-HPS WV-OOCAE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-OOCAE-HPS WV-OO5-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV405-AE-HPS WV-OOCAE-HPS WV-005.AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005.AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-OOCAE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV.005.AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005.AE-HPS WV.005.AE.HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS ' WV-OOCAE-HPS WV-00CAE-HPS

Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource

WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-OOCAE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-OOCAE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WVJJOCAE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE.H PS WV-005-AE-HPS WV.005-AE-H PS WV.OOBAE.HPS WV-OOCAE-HPS WV-OOCAE-HPS WV-00CAE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005.AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-OOCAE-HPS WV-OO5.AE.H PS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-OOCAE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-005-AE-HPS WV-OOCAE-HPS

82,801 53,723 60,09 58,65 54,15 2638 28,40' 50,03 46,35 69,66 72,34 81,38

82,211 6484 46,12$ 52,091 47,Ol 53,21 44,371 42,28 44,441 48,82 65,321 78,941 66,48 41,611 42,63. 36,30:

78,537 87,852 85,741 79,164 38,566 41,530 739145 67,765

101,844 62,799 42,959 118,971 120,179 94,793 67,432 76,157 68,730 77,789 64,873

61,818 64,972 71,373 95,488 115,399 97,186 60,842 62,323 53 069

~

4,108 238 2 439.477 1,668,761 59 38% 40 62%

WV Renewable CompllancePlan Annual Progress Report 2013 - Mon Power Potomac Edlson

1

EXHiBiT 6

5

Exhibit 6: Mon Power WV renewable energy resource credlts share of Harrison and Pieasants power stations

Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongshela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongaheia Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongaheia Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongaheia Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongaheia Power Monongaheia Power Monongahela Power Monongaheia Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongaheia Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongaheia Power Monongaheia Power Monongaheia Power Monongahela Power Monongaheia Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power

MSET90060101 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103

Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthraolte Coal Bltumlnous and Anthraclte Coal Bltumlnous and Anthraclte Coal Bitumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bltuminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bltuminous and Anthraclte Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bltuminous and Anthraolte Coal Bltumlnoua and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bituminoua and Anthraclte Coal Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal. Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal. Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnoue and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bltumlnous and Anthraclte Coal Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bltuminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bitumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthraclte Coal Bltuminous and Anthraclte Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthraclte Coal. Bltuminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bitumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthraclte Coal -Bituminous and Anthraolte Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bitumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bitumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltuminous and Anthraclte Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bitumlnous and Anthraclte Coal Bltuminous and Anthracite

-

-

--

-

wv wv

2012105 2012106 2012103 2012104 2012105 2012106 2012103 2012104 2012105 2012106 2012103 2012104 2012105 2012106 2012103 2012104 2012105 2012106 2012107 2012108 2012109 2012110 2012111 2012112 2013101 2013102 2013103 2013104 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109 2012107 2012108 20t2109 2012110 2012111 2012112 2013101 2013102 2013103 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109 2012107 2012108 2012109 2012110 2012111 2012112 2013101 2013102 2013103 2013104 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109

wv wv wv wv wv wv wv

wv wv wv

wv wv wv wv

wv wv wv wv wv wv

wv wv

wv WV wv wv

wv wv

wv wv

wv wv wv

wv

wv wv wv

wv wv

wv wv wv

wv wv wv wv

wv wv wv

wv

wv wv wv wv

wv wv wv wv

wv wv

-

-

446385 1to 73313 372712 1to 77287 389715 1 to 38272 412285.1 to 47281 439721 1to 55432 384306 1to 64848 389716 1to 9713 412286 1to 75418 453874 1to 68998 376248-It021868 389718-It021374 412288 1 to 25058 437543 1 to 31048 370756 1 to 15171 389719 1 to 26534 412289-1 to15410 437544.1 to 26240 460500 1 to 85456 483593.1 to 79513 517231 .Ito 38007 529955 1 to 45439 549660 1 to 94619 569365.1 to 81915 583953 1 to 94333 601674 1 to 72454 621166-1 to100063 646602 1to 60436 675387 Ito 78548 706937 Ito 92630 736491-It085071 764025 - 1 to 93731 794375 1to 79510 460501 -It083612 483594 Ito 67900 513437 1 to 36684 529956 1to 38543 549661 1 to 74985 569366 1 to 53897 583954.1 to 77545 601675 1 to 51763 621167.1 to51246 675388 1to 38649 705230 1to 72818 736033.1 to 92736 765327 1 to 89259 794376 1 to 69487 460502 1 to 67048 483595 1 to 78957 524840 1 to 54447 529957 1 to 41646 549662.1 to 92850 569367 1 to 82279 583955. Ito 94634 601676 1to 89672

-

-

-

-

621168 - 1 to 62240 646603 - 1 to 85919

-

675389 1to 81108 723434.1 to 82792 736352.1 to 58288 774517 1 to 78791 794377 * 1to 79695

WV Renewable Compliance Pian Annual Progress Repolt 2013 Mon Power Potamac Edison

Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Aiternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Aiternatlve Energy Resource Aiternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Reaource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource

12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12WV.0030.AE.ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-M-0031~AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-M-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AEACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV.0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV.0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-W.0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV.0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC I2-WV.0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-OO3O-AE.ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AEACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031AEdCTSC 12-W-0031-AE.ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC

Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource

12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC I2-WV-003t-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC

12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC

1

EXHIBIT 6

E x h i b i t 6:

~

.

,

.

Mon Power W renewable energy resource credits share of H a r r i s o n and Pleasants power stations

I_.

rqa,.~

Monongahela Power Monongshela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongaheia Power Monongshala Power Monongahsla Power Monongaheia Power Monongaheia Power Monongaheia Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongaheia Power Monongahela Power Monongaheia Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahsla Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahsla Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongaheia Power Monongahela Power Monongaheia Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power Monongahela Power )ondh*.h*;E;&& '.q FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Cow. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrrtEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Cow. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solution. Corp. FlrsIEnergy Solutions Core FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlms Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.

~ MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSETSOI 00101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060101 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103

~

~

- Bltumlnous and Anthraclte - Bitumlnous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite - Bltumlnous and Anthraclte - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bltumlnous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite

Coal Coal Coal. Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal. Coal. Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal. Coal Coal Coal Coal. Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal. Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal. Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal

--

Bituminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthraclte Bltumlnous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthraclte Bltumlnous and Anthracite Bltumlnous and Anthradte Bituminous and Anthracite Bitumlnous and Anthracite Bltumlnous and Anthracite Bltumlnous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite Bltumlnous and Anthraclte Bltumlnous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite Bltumlnous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite Bltuminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite Bltumlnous and Anthraclte Bituminous and Anthracite Bltuminous and Anthracite

y&F;

- Bltuminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthraclte - Bitumlnous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthraclte - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthraclte - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bituminous and Anthraclte - Bituminous and Anthraclte - Bituminous and Anthraclte - Bituminous and Anthracite - Bltuminous and Anthracite

Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal. Coal Coal Coal. Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal. Coal Coal Coal Coal Coal

-

--

Bitumlnous and Anthraclte Bituminous and Anthracite Bltuminous and Anthracite Bltumlnous and Anthraclte Bltuminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite Bituminous and Anthracite

~

~

wv wv

2012107 2012108 2012109 2012110 2012111 2012112 2013101 2013102 2013103 2013104 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109 2013110 2012107 2012108 2012109 2012110 2012111 2012112 2013101 2013102 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109 2013110 2013111 2013112 2013110 2013111 2013112 2013110 2013110

wv wv wv wv wv wv

wv wv wv

wv wv

wv wv wv wv

wv wv

wv wv wv

wv wv wv wv wv wv wv

wv wv wv wv wv

wv wv wv wv wv

wv

2012105 2012106 2012106 2012107 2012108 2012109 2012110 2012111 2012112 2013101 2013102 2013103 2013104 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109 2012/03 2012104 2012105 2012106 2012106 2012107 2012108 2012109 2012110

wv

wv wv

wv wv

wv wv

wv wv wv

wv wv

wv wv wv

wv wv

wv

wv wv

wv

wv wv

wv

wv wv

-

~

-

460504 1 to 24579 483597 1 to 32399 509701 1 to 30858 529959.1 to 24778 549664 1to 32884 569369 - 1 to 30011 583957 - 1 to 29472 601678-1 to21116 621170 1to 28890 646605 1to 30216 675391-It033501 705261 1to 29718 736023 1to 28481 773380 1to 18167 794379 1to 26192 823947 12761 to 28455 460505 1to 19880 483598 1 to 31082 509809.1 to 32803 529960 1 to 26132 549665 1 to 31828 569370-It025132 583958 1 to 33304 601679 1to 23439 675392 1to 22154 705262 1to 18600 735368 1to 30507 773381-It028888 794380 1to 33028 823943 1to 466029 858235 1to 331324 880410 - 1 to 99790 823944 1to 442265 859096 Ito 380545 880363 1to 180652 823945 369670 to 465226 823945 280449 to 369669 858236 1to 226140

-

-

-

--

--

-

460500 85457 to416046 483593 79514 to 387115 517231 38008 to 185040 529955.45440 to 221226 549660 94620 to 460662 569365.81916 to 398808 583953.94334 to 459269 601674.72455 to 352748 621166-100064to487163 646602.60437 to 294237 675387 78549 to 382419 706937.92631 to 450976 736491-85072to414173 764025.93732 to 456335 794375 79511 to 387101 372712.77268 to 376276 389715.38273 to 186331 412285.47282 to 230194 439721 .99480 to 269878 439721 .55433 to 99479 460501 .E3613 to 407067 483594 67901 to 330573 513437.36685 to 178599 529956.38544 to 187653

WV Renewable Compllance Plan Annual Progress Report 2013 Mon Power Potomac Edlaon

~

-

~ Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Aiternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternatlve

Alternative Aiternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Aiternatlve Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternatlve Alternative Alternative Alternatlve

Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Enerov Resource

~ 12-WV-0032-AE-ACT 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032AE-ACTSC 12-W.0032-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE.ACTSC 12-WV-0032-AE-ACTSC 12.W.0032-AE-ACTSC 12-WV~0032-AE-ACTSC 1Z-W-0032-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0032-AE-ACTSC 12WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WW0033-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0033-AE-ACTSC 12WV~0033-AE-ACTSC 1Z-W-0033-AE-ACTSC 1Z-W-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-W-OO33-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-W-OO33-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0033-AE.ACTSC 12-W-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WW0033-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC I&W.0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0031-AE-ACTSC

".

Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Reeource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Energy Resource Allernatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Aiternatlve Energy Resource

1Z-W-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-W.0029-AE-ACTSC 1Z-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0029-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0029-AE.ACTSC 12-W-0029-AE-ACTSC

lbWV-0030-AE~ACTSC IZ-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 12-W-0030-AE-ACTSC I~-WI.OO~O-AE-ACTSC I2-WV-0030-AE-ACTSC 1 2-W-0030-AE-ACTSC i2-W-0030-AE-ACTSC I 2-WV-0030.AE-ACTSC 12-W-0030-AE-ACTSC

2

EXHlBiT 6

,

Exhibit 6: Mon Power WY renewable energy resource credits share of Harrison and Pieasants power stations

.........:..: .'J,'.. :,*-i,+ >. .. &I&*&

FlrstEnergy Solutions 6o;p. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnargy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnatgy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FtrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlretEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergv Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FtrstEnargy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnsrgy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Cow. FlrstEnargy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FirstEnwgy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutlons Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. FlrstEnergy Solutions Corp. FirstEnergy Solutlons Corp.

MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060102 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90060103 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSETSO100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET9010010t MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100101 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102 MSET90100102

Coal -Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltuminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bltuminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal -Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal -Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal -Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal -Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthraclte Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal -Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal. Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bltumlnous and Anthraclte Coal. Bltumlnous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite Coal Bituminous and Anthracite

--

-----

----

-

--

wv wv wv wv wv

wv wv wv wv

wv

wv wv wv wv

wv wv wv wv

wv wv wv

wv wv wv wv wv wv

wv wv

wv wv

wv wv

wv

w wv

wv wv wv w

wv wv wv

wv wv

wv wv wv wv wv wv wv

wv wv wv wv wv wv wv

wv wv wv wv

wv

wv

wv wv wv

wv

wv

wv wv

2012111 2012112 2013101 2013102 2013103 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109 2012103 2012104 2012105 2012106 2012106 2012107 2012108 2012109 2012110 2012111 2012112 2013/01 2013102 2013103 2013104 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109 2013110 2012103 2012104 2012105 2012106 2012106 2012107 2012108 2012109 2012110 20121li 2012/12 2013101 2013102 2013103 2013104 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109 2013110 2013110 2013111 2013112 2012103 2012104 2012/05 2012106 2012106 2012107 2012108 2012109 2012110

2012111 2012112 2013101 2013102 2013105 2013106 2013107 2013108 2013109

.- - .- .. .. 549661 .74986 to 365070 569366.53898 to 262404 583954.77546 to 377536 601675.51764 to 252015 621167 51247 to 249496 675388 38650 to 188168 705230 72819 to 354519 736033 92737 to 451494 765327 89260 to 434565 794376 69488 to 338304 384306 64849 to 315716 389716 9714 to 47290 412286 75419 to 367181 453874 123825 to 335923 453874 68999 to 123824 460502 67049 to 326425 483595.78958 to 384408 524840 54448 to 265079 529957 41647 to 202756 549662 92851 to 452049 569367 82280 to 400582 583955 94635 to 460734 601676 89673 to 436577 621168 62241 to 303020 646603 85920 to 418305 675389 81109 to 394879 723434.82793 to 403080 736352 58289 to 283778 774517 78792 to 383598 794377 79696 to 388002 823945-lto280448 376248 .21869 to 284376 389718 21375 to 277946 412288 2505910 325853 437543 59710 to 403753 437543 31049 to 59709 460504 24580 to 319619 483597.32400 to 421315 509701-30859t0401272 529959.24779 to 322213 549664 32885 to 427626 569369 30012 to 390268 583957 .29473 to 383256 601678 -21117to274599 621170 28891 to 375695 646605.30217 to 392934 675391 33502 to 435654 705261 29719 to 386455 736023 28482 to 370375 773380.18168 to 236247 794379 26193 to 340609 823947 1 to 12760 823947 28456 to 370038 850495 1 to 397950 880498 1 to 452989 370756.15172 to 197293 389719.26535 to 345050 412289 15411to 200403 437544 50464 to 341228 437544 26241 to 50463 460505 19881 to 258517 483598 31083 to 404185 509809-32804to426567 529960 26133 to 339825 549665.31829 to 413893 569370.25133 to 326822 583958.33305 10 433092 601679 23440 to 304807 675392-22155to288093 705262.18601 to 241881 735368.30508 to 396713 773381 28889 to 375667 794380 33029 to 429504

WV Renewable CompliancePlan Annual Progress Repolt 2013. Mon Power Potomac Edison

-~

--

-

-

--

-

-

-

Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Aiternatlve Energy Resource Aiternatlve Energy Resource Aitematlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Altsrnatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Aiternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Altsmative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternstiw Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource A l t e r n a t h Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternatlve Ensrgy Resource Alternatlve Energy Resource Alternative Energy Resource

12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC

313,693

124'V-0033*AE-ACTSC

382,065

12-WV-0033.AE-ACTSC 12.WV.0033.AE.ACTSC 12-WV-0033.AE-ACTSC IZWV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC 12-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC E-WV-0033-AE-ACTSC

3

301,690 399,788 281,368

265,939 223,281 366,206 344779 396,476

EXHIBIT 6

Exhlbit 6: Mon Power W renewable energy resource credits share of Harrison and Pleasants power statlons

FlrstEnergy Solutions Cor FlrstEnergy Solutions Cor FirstEnergy Solutions Cor

Total Credits Generated by Pleasants Power Stallon on behalf of Allegheny Energy Supply Total credns Generated by Pkasents Power Statron on behelf of Monongahda Power Company Total Credits Generated by Pleasants Power Station on behalf of Allegheny Energy Supply (through 10/08/2013) Total Credits Generated by Pleasants Power Stenon o n behalf of Monongahela P o w Commny [through iWOW2013) Percentage of Credlts Generated by Plearants Power Slation on behalf of Allegheny Energy Supply2 Percentage of Credits Ganeraied by Pleasante Power Stallon on behalf of Monongahsla Power Company' Total Credits Generated by Pleasants Power Station on behalf of Allegheny Energy Supply (beglnnlng 10/09/2013) Total Credlls Generated by Pirnssnta Pow61 Stdnon on behalf of Monongahela Power Company (beginning fWG9l2013) Percentage of Credits Generated by Pleasants Power Station on behalf of Allegheny Energy Supply Percenhge of Credlt.9 Generated by Pleasants P o w Shtion on behalf of Monongahela P m Company

13 968 833 976 437 11 545 623 976 437 92 20% 7 80% 2,423,210 IC0 00% 0 00%

-

1 The ownershlp split for Harrison PS prior to the swap was 79.36% for AE Supply and 20.54% for Mon Power. Mon Power and AE Supply determined the appropriate credlt spllt for October based on actual generatlon from October 1 through October 8. The slight difference in final percentages shown for 2013 through October, to Mon Power's favor, Is due to the aggregation of the data on a monthly basis.

-

2 The ownership split for Herrlson PS prlor to the swap was 92.31% for AE Supply end 7.69% for Mon Power. Mon Power and AE Supply determined the approprlate credit split for October based on actual generation from October f through October 8. The siight difference in final percentages shown for 2013 through October, to Mon Power's favor, Is due to the aggregation of the data on a monthly basis.

-

WV Renewable Cornpllanoe Plan Annual Pmgress Report 2013 Mon Power Potomac Edisan

4