SlideLegend

Frame A-18 · Report

The Rise of the Sharing Economy

Publisher
EY (Ernst & Young)
Year
2015
Topic
Business & Marketing
Published here

Audio briefing · A-18

Listen to it 2:14

Four categories.

Read the transcript

Four categories. That is what survives most clearly of an EY report called The Rise of the Sharing Economy, published in 2015, after its original hosting on EY's own site went dark and a third party mirror that once held a copy also disappeared. What remains is a framework other writers still reach for when they need a clean way to talk about a messy category of business. The first category is recirculation of goods. This covers marketplaces that extend the life of something already owned by reselling or redistributing it, rather than letting it sit unused or go to landfill. One later article tracing this category's roots points back to the 1990s, naming eBay and Craigslist as the pioneers that made buying and selling secondhand goods online a mainstream habit rather than a garage sale. The second category is increased utilization of durable assets. This is the category most people probably picture first when they hear the phrase sharing economy: platforms that let underused durable goods, a car sitting in a driveway most of the day, a spare room, get used more intensively by more people. Car sharing and home sharing both sit here. The third category is exchange of services, covering platforms that connect people who need a task done with people willing to do it, a labor marketplace model rather than a goods marketplace. The fourth category is sharing of productive assets, a narrower and less consumer facing idea: tools, equipment or resources shared because they are used for production rather than personal consumption. What cannot be confirmed here is much else about the report. It is not certain whether the specific edition behind this framework was a global EY publication or one focused on India, since search evidence points toward an India specific edition while the way the framework gets cited elsewhere reads as fully general. Given that uncertainty, what follows sticks to the one piece of content multiple sources independently confirm: the four categories themselves, and the examples used to illustrate the first of them.

What EY’s The Rise of the Sharing Economy actually argued in full is no longer easy to establish. The report’s original home on EY’s own site returns a not-found error today, and a third-party mirror that once carried a copy, hosted by a Korean sharing-economy nonprofit, now returns a “gone” response rather than a page. What survives, confirmed through how other writers cite the report rather than through the report itself, is a single piece of content solid enough to build a page around: a four-category framework for sorting what “sharing economy” actually covers.

Four categories, one framework

EY’s framework splits the sharing economy into four distinct types of activity, each with its own economics and its own kind of platform.

CategoryWhat it coversExample
Recirculation of goodsReselling or redistributing already-owned itemseBay, Craigslist
Increased utilization of durable assetsUnderused durable goods used more intensivelyCar-sharing, home-sharing
Exchange of servicesConnecting people who need a task done with people who can do itTask/labor marketplaces
Sharing of productive assetsTools or equipment shared for production, not personal useEquipment-rental platforms

A category older than the phrase itself

The first category, recirculation of goods, is the one with the clearest documented history. A later article tracing the category’s origins places it in the 1990s, a good fifteen years before “sharing economy” became a common phrase at all. It is worth noting how much older this category is than the label now attached to it: the framework retroactively brings a decades-old business model under a newer name, rather than describing something wholly new.

eBay and Craigslist, named as the pioneers

That same later article names eBay and Craigslist specifically as the platforms that made online resale a mainstream consumer habit rather than a niche activity conducted at a literal garage sale. Neither company was built to be part of a “sharing economy” story; both simply let people list things they already owned and no longer wanted, and the category grew up around what they had already normalized. The other three categories in EY’s framework are newer in spirit even where the underlying activity is old. Increased utilization of durable assets is probably what most people picture first when they hear “sharing economy”: a car that sits unused most of the day, or a spare room, made available to more people than the original owner alone. Exchange of services shifts the model from goods to labor, platforms connecting someone who needs a task done with someone willing to do it. Sharing of productive assets is the narrowest and least consumer-facing of the four: tools, equipment or resources shared specifically because they support production rather than personal use.

An honest gap

The report is dated 2015 across the secondary sources that cite it, though that single, confident-looking year sits on top of a genuinely uncertain identification question that cannot be fully resolved here. Search evidence points most strongly toward an India-focused edition of this report, with a longer title naming India specifically. But the way the framework gets cited elsewhere, in a general discussion of circular business models, with no India-specific detail attached, reads as though the citing author encountered the four-category framework in a fully general form, not tied to any one country’s data. Rather than guess which is correct, or invent India-specific statistics that were never verified here, what follows sticks to the one thing multiple independent sources confirm without contradiction: the four categories, and the eBay-and-Craigslist example attached to the first of them.

If a current EY report on the sharing economy exists, it would need to be sourced fresh from EY’s own site rather than assumed to carry the same four-category structure. A report published in 2015 describes a business model that has since matured, changed regulatory treatment in multiple countries, and in some cases consolidated down to a handful of dominant platforms; it is not automatically still an accurate map of the territory a decade later.

Slide check · 4 questions

Check yourself

Question 01 of 04

How many categories does EY's sharing-economy framework divide the concept into?

Show the answer

B · FourThe report organizes the sharing economy into four categories.

Question 02 of 04

Which category covers marketplaces like eBay and Craigslist?

Show the answer

A · Recirculation of goodsRecirculation of goods covers reselling and redistributing already-owned items, with eBay and Craigslist as pioneering examples.

Question 03 of 04

Which category covers platforms that let people use underused durable assets, like cars or spare rooms, more intensively?

Show the answer

B · Increased utilization of durable assetsThis category covers car-sharing, home-sharing and similar intensified use of durable goods.

Question 04 of 04

Which category covers the sharing of tools or equipment used for production rather than personal consumption?

Show the answer

A · Sharing of productive assetsSharing of productive assets is the narrowest category, covering production-oriented rather than consumer sharing.